In the publication “Typifications, new combinations and new synonyms in IndianImpatiens(Balsaminaceae)” by Singh, R. K.et al. (2021), the authors used pseudoscientific theoretical background, utilized material collected by other persons without citing the source of data in support of their claims, and made serious errors in the determination and delimitation ofImpatienstaxa occuring in Himalayas and adjacent areas. They proposed new combinations and statuses without sufficient field and literature studies and failed to show convincing evidences in their treatments. Their documentation lacks important details, like authorship of the published pictures, locations and dates of pictures, or measurements of plant parts; the whole documentation has geographically biased gaps – in case of Western Himalayan or Sikkimese taxa, there is almost no original illustrative material. Finally, they falsely claimed extensive field studies in Western Himalaya. This paper reinstates 19 species and 1 variety synonymised by Singhet al. (2021) with scientific evidences based on illustrations from types and colour photographs from fresh collections.
Impatiens cothurnoides C.E.C.Fisch. (Balsaminaceae) is rediscovered after a gap of nearly 90 years in the Garo Hills of Meghalaya, North-East India. A detailed description and photographic illustrations based on live plant materials are provided for its easy identification. The species, known only from sparse collections, is assessed as Endangered under IUCN Red List Categories & Criteria. The actual distributional range of the species is discussed and a lectotype designated for the name.
The taxonomic identity of Impatiens laxiflora Edgew. is assessed historically and the name I. leggei Pusalkar & D.K.Singh is found conspecific and synonymized. The species commonly treated in China as I. laxiflora Edgew. is studied and its true identity ascertained as I. desmantha Hook.f., with two new synonyms: I. gracilipes Hook.f. and I. recticalcarata S.Akiyama. All three other closely allied species of I. laxiflora Edgew. (I. crassicaudex Hook.f., I. infirma Hook.f. and I. sunkoshiensis S.Akiyama, H.Ohba & Wakab.) are also studied and discussed. We provide updated descriptions with illustrations for all the five species, an identification key to the species, and designate lectotypes for the four names I. laxiflora, I. desmantha, I. crassicaudex and I. infirma.
1 September 2020 in Biodiversity: Research and Conservation
Impatiens cathcartiiHook.f. is recollected almost after a century, its taxonomic identity, description from fresh collection, coloured illustrations are made along with notes on typification of the name. Taxonomic identity ofI. serratifoliaHook.f. along with its delimitation from closely related species is discussed, coloured illustrations with comparison of flowers with the closest species and notes on the typification of the name are also discussed.
Erigeron multiradiatus (Asteraceae: Astereae: Conyzinae) and Tibetiodes himalaica (Asteraceae: Astereae: Asterinae) are often misidentified due to their morphological similarity and variation in some morphological characters. The present communication aims to resolve the identity crisis of these two species based on detailed morphological studies of freshly collected as well as herbarium specimens (including types), SEM studies of cypselas and molecular study with one nuclear and one chloroplast marker (ITS and trnLF). The morphological analysis showed that the two species differ in involucres and flower colour, with very clear differences in macro- and micro-morphological features of the cypselas. The molecular study also showed clear distinction between these two taxa. Additionally, a lectotype is designated for Erigeron multiradiatus.