The article develops our understanding of social capital by analyzing social capital as an organizational phenomenon. The analysis is based on qualitative data consisting of interviews and documents obtained from six different kindergartens in Norway. Kindergartens are used as a “prism” through which we can understand how social capital is formed—and the mechanisms that shape the development of various forms of networks within welfare organizations. More specifically we look at drop-in kindergartens. The specific purpose of these kindergartens is to provide open and inclusive arenas that promote integration and community. We find that the kindergartens vary in the degree to which they succeed in building bridging forms of networks and communities. Using concepts from organizational theory and Wenger’s (1998) theory of communities of practice, we find that formal organizational factors such as ownership, organizational goals, profiling, location, and educational content impact the formation of bridging forms of social capital. The composition of the user groups and the user groups’ motivation for participating most clearly affect the conditions for community formation. The composition of the user groups is the result of a number of organizational factors and organizational mechanisms. Kindergartens that have a heterogeneous user group, and a user group with a community orientation (Morse 2006), are more successful at creating bridging types of social networks.
22 September 2023 in Journal of Professions and Organization
This article discusses how professionals’ efforts to reach policy goals engender boundary work. Analyses of interviews with service professionals in three welfare services in Norway which collaborate to implement the Introduction Program for refugees show how conflicting logics in services pose dilemmas for service professionals, and that political ideals of collaborative governance and integrated services are hard to put into practice. Service professionals resolve these dilemmas by engaging in various forms of boundary work, and the scope for boundary work is conditioned by the different service logics they operate under. Welfare service professionals collaborate to reach three policy goals—qualification of refugees, empowerment of users, and providing equity in services. The analysis shows that conflicting service logics result in boundary work practices that make coordination of, and collaboration between, services difficult, as services do not agree on how to interpret, and share responsibility for enacting, policy goals. The outcome of boundary work practices is a reshuffling of responsibilities—and a redelegation of tasks—which in principle should be shared, onto specific services. Different interpretations of policy goals instigate boundary work among welfare service professionals, which not only involves struggles over jurisdictional boundaries, but also negotiations over whom owns a policy problem, and over how to define and represent the problem. The findings from this study encourage researchers to further explore how policy goals are used as boundary objects in professionals’ negotiations over jurisdictional boundaries, in order to further understand what triggers and shapes boundary work among professionals.
3 March 2025 in Nordisk välfärdsforskning | Nordic Welfare Research
Establishing the object of study is a topic that is rarely addressed in the methodological literature. In this article, we explore methodological strategies for establishing the object of a study, and the implications of the establishment of the object for the research process. We propose a line of inquiry and a set of methodological prerequisites for establishing a researchable object and identifying appropriate data to represent the object. Our discussion centers on the importance of the research object in five critical phases of the research process: (1) establishing the object, (2) bounding the object, (3) identifying instruments of observation, (4) establishing empirical facts, and (5) extending the interpretation. We defer to our example of researching the transformations in the landscape of voluntarism in the Norwegian welfare society to illustrate the work involved in each phase. The article provides two key insights. On the one hand, it is essential to acknowledge that no single study can provide comprehensive answers to a broad and complex problem or topic. Treating the entire topic or problem as the research object – or taking the object for granted –can obscure the research process and analysis, ultimately undermining both the credibility and the contribution of a study. On the other hand, by accepting this limitation and committing to the rigorous work of constructing a clear and defensible research object, researchers can generate meaningful and credible knowledge about a specific aspect of the broader issue that initially motivated the inquiry. The focused approach we outline in this article not only facilitates informed discussion of the topic in light of new insights brought forward by a study, but also contributes to identifying what more must be known to lay the foundation for extending our knowledge of a research problem or topic in a field.
Public governance is increasingly being challenged by various forms of turbulence. Consequently, there is emerging awareness of the need for more robust governance strategies to manage turbulence and avoid crises. While public organizations have widely used digital technologies for decades, the relationship between digital technologies and robust governance remains largely unexplored. This chapter explores if and how digital platforms can support strategies for robust governance by examining three empirical cases. The empirical evidence illustrates how digital platforms were integral to two robustness strategies and how they can serve as critical infrastructure for robust governance in different policy areas. Conceptually, digital platforms have considerable potential as instruments for robust governance, well beyond what we observed in different municipalities and policy areas. However, realizing the potential of digital platforms in governance strategies seems to be contingent on addressing issues related to multi-level governance, digital maturity, and developing an ecosystem governance mindset.