Gulnara Ismukhanova

Dr. Gulnara Ismukhanova

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

4Years (2023-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 July 2025 in Scientific Data
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MKMarta Kowal
Marta Kowal
PSPiotr Sorokowski
Piotr Sorokowski
BGBiljana Gjoneska
Biljana Gjoneska
KPKatarzyna Pisanski
Katarzyna Pisanski
GPGerit Pfuhl
Gerit Pfuhl
Filipe PrazeresFilipe Prazeres
Filipe Prazeres
Psychological studies on close relationships have often overlooked cultural diversity, dynamic processes, and potentially universal principles that shape intimate partnerships. To address the limited generalizability of previous research and advance our understanding of romantic love experiences, mate preferences, and physical attractiveness, we conducted a large-scale cross-cultural survey study on these topics. A total of 404 researchers collected data in 45 languages from April to August 2021, involving 117,293 participants from 175 countries. Aside from standard demographic questions, the survey included valuable information on variables relevant to romantic relationships: intimate, passionate, and committed love within romantic relationships, physical-attractiveness enhancing behaviors, gender equality endorsement, collectivistic attitudes, personal history of pathogenic diseases, relationship quality, jealousy, personal involvement in sexual and/or emotional infidelity, relational mobility, mate preferences, and acceptance of sugar relationships. The resulting dataset provides a rich resource for investigating patterns within, and associations across, a broad range of variables relevant to romantic relationships, with extensive opportunities to analyze individual experiences worldwide.

1 February 2025 in International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE)
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SNSaniya Nurgaliyeva
Saniya Nurgaliyeva
SZSaule Zeinolla
Saule Zeinolla
AAAssel Aben
Assel Aben
SISaule Iskendirova
Saule Iskendirova
Gulnara IsmukhanovaGulnara Ismukhanova
Gulnara Ismukhanova
Over the years of independence, Kazakhstan has developed a higher education (HE) system that incorporates both national characteristics and international standards. However, the system still struggles to meet new challenges, and its scale, while comparable to global standards, does not yet reflect the growing requirements for quality education essential for ensuring competitiveness. The study aims to evaluate the extent of variability in Kazakhstan’s policies as they navigate between global challenges and local objectives in the pursuit of higher education quality. A quantitative method was utilized to collect and analyze the study data to identify relationships, test hypotheses, and draw generalizations. The study sample consists of a total of 1,200 educators from various universities. The study findings revealed that Kazakhstan is rapidly advancing to the third stage of HE internationalization, striking a balance between importing and aspiring to export HE. This study is important as it provides valuable insights into how Kazakhstan’s modern universities can effectively manage the intersection of global challenges and regional obligations to enhance the quality of HE.

30 September 2025 in Journal of Central Asian Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Gulnara IsmukhanovaGulnara Ismukhanova
Gulnara Ismukhanova
MAMoldir Akmadi
Moldir Akmadi
This article aims to provide a systematic analysis of the public discourse of leading Kazakh political experts from the perspective of the theory of spiral dynamics (C. Graves, D. Beck, C. Cowan). In the context of political reforms, growing public mistrust, and institutional transformations, expert discourse serves as a channel for articulating values. The aim of the study is to identify and interpret the dominant and auxiliary value memes based on the analysis of public interviews, articles, speeches, and publications in social networks. Methodologically, it is based on qualitative and quantitative content analysis of more than 670,000 words of direct speech, Kazakh experts Dosym Satpayev, Sanzhar Bokayev, Andrei Chebotarev, and Karlygash Yezhenova. In the course of the study, the data were encoded according to the developed matrix, and the consistency index for Cohen’s Kappa was 0.84, which demonstrates a high level of reliability. In the process of coding, an eight-level model of spiral dynamics was applied, namely beige, purple, red, blue, orange, green, yellow, and turquoise. The analysis also used MAXQDA and Python software tools. The results of the study showed the presence of stable value polyphony in public statements of experts. The most frequently encountered value levels in their discourse were blue, demonstrating institutional order and accountability; orange, showing rationality, efficiency, development, and green, which demonstrates humanism, social justice, and dialogue. Moreover, each expert’s value meme structure varies, forming unique configurations that reflect their analytical styles and cognitive priorities.

1 September 2023 in Journal of Philosophy, Culture and Political Science
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
Gulnara IsmukhanovaGulnara Ismukhanova
Gulnara Ismukhanova
GUG. Urozbayeva
G. Urozbayeva
Аннотация: Мақалада 2011 жылдан бүгінгі күнге дейінгі Қазақстандағы этномедиацияның қалыптасу кезеңдері қарастырылған. Заманауи конфликтологиялық теорияларға шолу жасау қазіргі батыстық конфликтологиялық ой-пікірдің ұстанымдары мен қайшылықтан барлық жолдармен құтылуға ұмтылатын дәстүрлі қазақ қоғамының ұстанымдары мен құндылықтары арасындағы кейбір сәйкессіздіктерді анықтады. Авторлар даму кезеңдерін жіктеуге, Қазақстандағы этномедиацияның даму ерекшеліктерін сипаттауға және түсінуге әрекет жасады. Қазіргі заманғы батыстық конфликтологияның негізгі қағидалары қазақ қоғамындағы медиация тәсілдерінде көрініс тауып, жинақталған, алайда қазақтардың дәстүрлі құндылықтарымен байланысты өзіндік ерекшеліктері де бар. Мақалада қазақстандық қоғамның заманауи дамуы жағдайында әлеуметтік қақтығыстарды институттандырудың маңыздылығы атап өтілген. Түйінді сөздер: медиация, этникалық медиация, әлеуметтік қақтығыстар, ұлтаралық қақтығыстар, полиэтникалық. Аннотация: В статье исследуются этапы становления этномедиации в Казахстане с 2011 года до сегодняшнего дня. Обзор современных конфликтологических теорий позволил выявить некоторое несоответствие принципов современной западной конфликтологической мысли с принципами и ценностями традиционного казахского общества, стремящегося всеми силами избавиться от конфликта. Авторами предпринята попытка дать классификацию этапов развития, описать и осознать особенности развития этномедиации в Казахстане. Основные принципы современной западной конфликтологии находят свое отражение и воплощение в подходах в медиации в казахстанском обществе, однако, существуют и свои особенности, связанные с традиционными ценностями казахов. В статье подчеркивается важность институционализации социальных конфликтов в контексте современного развития казахстанского общества. Ключевые слова: медиация, этномедиация, социальные конфликты, межэтнические конфликты, полиэтничность. Annotation: The article examines the stages of the formation of ethnomediation in Kazakhstan from 2011 to the present day. A review of modern conflictological theories has revealed some discrepancy between the principles of modern Western conflictological thought and the principles and values of the traditional Kazakh society striving to get rid of the conflict by all means. The authors made an attempt to classify the stages of development, describe and understand the features of the development of ethnomediation in Kazakhstan. The basic principles of modern Western conflictology are reflected and embodied in approaches to mediation in Kazakhstani society, however, there are also their own characteristics associated with the traditional values of the Kazakhs. The article emphasizes the importance of the institutionalization of social conflicts in the context of the modern development of Kazakhstani society. Key words: mediation, ethnic mediation, social conflicts, interethnic conflicts, polyethnicity.

30 March 2026 in Journal of Philosophy Culture and Political Science
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
Gulnara IsmukhanovaGulnara Ismukhanova
Gulnara Ismukhanova
MAM.а. Akmadi
M.а. Akmadi
This article examines the value systems revealed in public discussions of four contemporary Kazakh art activists: Saule Suleimenova, Saule Dyussembina, Vladislav Sludsky and Galiya Toremuratova. The article employs an analytical approach based on Spiral Dynamics theory and conducts a content analysis of 61,263 words from digital publications, interviews, public statements, and other publicly available materials. The study identifies the primary and secondary vMEMEs presented in these narratives. It is studied how these value structures are connected with the socio-political landscape of Kazakhstan. For all significant units of the body, a coding matrix based on the eight-level model «spiral dynamics» was used, which allowed a comparative analysis of different cases. The results show that all four artists operate in complex value systems, with «orange», «green» and «yellow» being the main vMEMEs influencing their communication practices. These levels demonstrate a general orientation towards innovation, civic humanism, systematic reflection and ethical criticism. Secondary memes, especially blue and purple, serve as cultural and moral foundations, while turquoise selectively appears in discussions related to collective healing and universal dignity. Although each artist has a unique value profile, their collective understanding reveals a broader movement towards postmaterialistic and integrative forms of civil expression in Kazakhstan. By focusing on value discourse rather than public perception, the study highlights the capacity of art activism to shape cultural meanings, harmonize collective identities, and express new ethical perspectives in a rapidly changing society. Keywords: art; art-activism; spiral dynamics; visual politics; value systems. Keywords: vMEMEs, art, art-activism, Spiral Dynamics, visual politics, value systems.

5 November 2025 in Journal of Philosophy Culture and Political Science
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Gulnara IsmukhanovaGulnara Ismukhanova
Gulnara Ismukhanova
MAM. A. Akmadi
M. A. Akmadi
БЙБ. С. Йоунссон
Б. С. Йоунссон
Under conditions of increasing political transformation and change in the realities of Kazakhstan, the human rights discourse becomes increasingly important as a site for the articulation of alternative value systems and critical reflection of public order. This study aims to identify levels of value consciousness in the public rhetoric of four leading Kazakh human rights defenders based on the theory of spiral dynamics. The study analyzes the texts of four human rights defenders with a legal education, actively participating in public space between 2016 and 2024. The methodology of work is based on a combined content-analysis, paragraph coding and construction of a categorical matrix vMEMEs, adapted to the human rights and legal discourse. The reliability of the coding was tested using the Cohen’s Kappa method (κ=0.82), which indicates a high degree of consistency in the evaluations. The results of the analysis show the dominance of three levels of value consciousness, namely blue, where it is about normative, legal and order. Next is the green, which implies inclusion, solidarity and humanism, and the yellow, which includes systemic thinking, reflexivity, and adaptability. For each of the speakers, individual variations in the configuration of levels and rhetorical strategies are fixed. Elements of red, violet and, in some cases, turquoise levels were also identified, which indicates the existence of transitional forms of consciousness and strategic adaptation. The scientific novelty of the research is the first empirical application of the theory of spiral dynamics to the analysis of human rights rhetoric in the Kazakh context. The theoretical significance lies in the development of a cognitive-value approach to the study of civil consciousness. The practical applicability of the results consists in the possibility to use the proposed methodology for monitoring value transformations, predicting the evolution of civic rhetoric, as well as for educational and primary education purposes. Keywords: spiral dynamics, human rights discourse, vMEMEs, social conflicts, Kazakhstan, civic consciousness.