Holli Sargeant

Ms. Holli Sargeant

Faculty of Law, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, UK
orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
21 November 2022 in AI and Ethics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
HSHolli Sargeant
Holli Sargeant
Consider how much data is created and used based on our online behaviours and choices. Converging foundational technologies now enable analytics of the vast data required for machine learning. As a result, businesses now use algorithmic technologies to inform their processes, pricing and decisions. This article examines the implications of algorithmic decision-making in consumer credit markets from economic and normative perspectives. This article fills a gap in the literature to explore a multi-disciplinary approach to framing economic and normative issues for algorithmic decision-making in the private sector. This article identifies optimal and suboptimal outcomes in the relationships between companies and consumers. The economic approach of this article demonstrates that more data allows for more information which may result in better contracting outcomes. However, it also identifies potential risks of inaccuracy, bias and discrimination, and ‘gaming’ of algorithmic systems for personal benefit. Then, this article argues that these economic costs have normative implications. Connecting economic outcomes to a normative analysis contextualises the challenges in designing and regulating ML fairly. In particular, it identifies the normative implications of the process, as much as the outcome, concerning trust, privacy and autonomy and potential bias and discrimination in ML systems. Credit scoring, as a case study, elucidates the issues relating to private companies. Legal norms tend to mirror economic theory. Therefore, this article frames the critical economic and normative issues required for further regulatory work.

26 July 2022
Verified
Conference Paper
Open access
MZMiri Zilka
Miri Zilka
HSHolli Sargeant
Holli Sargeant
AWAdrian Weller
Adrian Weller
We present a survey of tools used in the criminal justice system in the UK in three categories: data infrastructure, data analysis, and risk prediction. Many tools are currently in deployment, offering potential benefits, including improved efficiency and consistency. However, there are also important concerns. Transparent information about these tools, their purpose, how they are used, and by whom is difficult to obtain. Even when information is available, it is often insufficient to enable a satisfactory evaluation. More work is needed to establish governance mechanisms to ensure that tools are deployed in a transparent, safe and ethical way. We call for more engagement with stakeholders and greater documentation of the intended goal of a tool, how it will achieve this goal compared to other options, and how it will be monitored in deployment. We highlight additional points to consider when evaluating the trustworthiness of deployed tools and make concrete proposals for policy.

25 February 2025 in Artificial Intelligence and Law
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
HSHolli Sargeant
Holli Sargeant
AIAhmed Izzidien
Ahmed Izzidien
FSFelix Steffek
Felix Steffek
This paper addresses a critical gap in legal analytics by developing and applying a novel taxonomy for topic classification of summary judgment cases in the United Kingdom. Using a curated dataset of summary judgment cases, we use the Large Language Model Claude 3 Opus to explore functional topics and trends. We find that Claude 3 Opus correctly classified the topic with an accuracy of 87.13% and an F1 score of 0.87. The analysis reveals distinct patterns in the application of summary judgments across various legal domains. As case law in the United Kingdom is not originally labelled with keywords or a topic filtering option, the findings not only refine our understanding of the thematic underpinnings of summary judgments but also illustrate the potential of combining traditional and AI-driven approaches in legal classification. Therefore, this paper provides a new and general taxonomy for UK law. The implications of this work serve as a foundation for further research and policy discussions in the field of judicial administration and computational legal research methodologies.

23 September 2024 in Computer
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
UBUmang Bhatt
Umang Bhatt
HSHolli Sargeant
Holli Sargeant
Algorithmic resignation is a strategic approach for managing the use of artificial intelligence (AI) by embedding governance directly into AI systems. Organizations can thus balance the benefits of automation with the need for human oversight.


1 January 2024 in SSRN Electronic Journal
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
COCathy O'NEil
Cathy O'NEil
HSHolli Sargeant
Holli Sargeant
JAJacob Appel
Jacob Appel
How does a regulator know if an algorithm is compliant with existing anti-discrimination law? This is an urgent question, as algorithmic decision-making tools play an increasingly significant role in the lives of humans, especially at critical junctures such as getting into college, getting a job, getting a mortgage, housing, or insurance. In each of these regulated situations, moreover, the legal meaning of unlawful discrimination is different and context dependent. Regulators lack consensus on how to audit algorithms for discrimination. Recent legal precedent provides some clarity for review and provides the basis of the framework for algorithmic auditing outlined in this article. This article provides a review of precedent, a novel framework which explicitly decouples technical data science questions from legal and regulatory questions, an exploration of the framework’s relationship to disparate impact. The framework promotes algorithmic accountability and transparency by focusing on explainability to regulators and the public. Through case studies in student lending and insurance, we demonstrate operationalizing audits to enforce fairness standards. Our goal is an adaptable, robust framework to guide anti-discrimination algorithm auditing until legislative interventions emerge. As an ancillary benefit, this framework is robust, easily explainable, and implementable with immediate impacts to many public and private stakeholders.