A goal for the validation of computational electromagnetics (CEM) is to provide the community with a simple computational method that can be used to predict the assessment of electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) data as it would be undertaken by individuals or teams of engineers. The benefits of being able to do this include quantifying the comparison of data that has hitherto only been assessed qualitatively, to provide the ability to track differences between model iterations, and to provide a means of capturing the variability and range of opinions of groups and teams of workers. The feature selective validation (FSV) technique shows great promise for achieving this goal. This paper presents a detailed analysis of the FSV method, setting it firmly in the context of previous comparison techniques; it suggests the relationship between validation of graphically presented data and the psychology of visual perception. A set of applicability tests to judge the effectiveness of computer-based CEM validation techniques is also proposed. This paper is followed by a detailed comparison with visual assessment, which is presented in Part II
21 August 2006 in IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility
The feature selective validation (FSV) method has been proposed as a technique to allow the objective, quantified, comparison of data for inter alia validation of computational electromagnetics. In the companion paper "Feature selective validation for validation of computational electromagnetics. Part I-The FSV method," the method was outlined in some detail. This paper addresses two specific issues related to the implementation of the FSV method, namely "how well does it produce results that agree with visual assessment?" and "what benefit can it provide in a practical validation environment?" The first of these questions is addressed by comparing the FSV output to the results of an extensive survey of EMC engineers from several countries. The second is approached via a case study analysis
1 September 1995 in Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences
Reverberation chambers are attractive electromagnetic compatibility test facilities, both economically and technically. Careful design and analysis of these facilities are important, if the results obtained are to be treated with a high level of confidence. Numerical modeling is an important part of the process of reverberation chamber design and analysis. Hence, it is important that the modeling techniques to be used are appropriately validated. Much of the published work to date takes either a statistical or a deterministic view of validation. This paper provides validation evidence for a low-resolution transmission line matrix (TLM) model of a reverberation chamber in a manner approximating the way in which the chamber is used, i.e., validating based on the effects of a simple device under test. A variety of statistical and heuristic approaches have been used to quantify the level of agreement, intending to set the likely lower bound for the quality of comparisons between simulations and measurements. While not drawing any "universal" conclusions about the veracity of the TLM technique, the paper concludes that a relatively simple model of a reverberation chamber provides a useful analysis of the chamber with close comparisons between modeled and measured data.