The food system plays a crucial role in mitigating climate change. Even if fossil fuel emissions are halted immediately, current trends in global food systems may prevent the achieving of the Paris Agreement’s climate targets. The high degree of variability and uncertainty involved in calculating diet-related greenhouse gas emissions limits the ability to evaluate reduction potentials to remain below a global warming of 1.5 or 2 degrees. This study assessed Western European dietary patterns while accounting for uncertainty and variability. An extensive literature review provided value ranges for climate impacts of animal-based foods to conduct an uncertainty analysis via Monte Carlo simulation. The resulting carbon footprints were assessed against food system-specific greenhouse gas emission thresholds. The range and absolute value of a diet carbon footprint become larger the higher the amount of products with highly varying emission values in the diet. All dietary pattern carbon footprints overshoot the 1.5 degrees threshold. The vegan, vegetarian, and diet with low animal-based food intake were predominantly below the 2 degrees threshold. Omnivorous diets with more animal-based product content trespassed them. Reducing animal-based foods is a powerful strategy to decrease emissions. However, further mitigation strategies are required to achieve climate goals.
Currently, biomass utilization is predominantly directed toward bioenergy (BE) production. Yet, alternative pathways such as biochar carbon removal (BCR) and bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) are emerging options within negative emission technologies. Given limited biomass resources, determining their most beneficial allocation remains a pressing question. This study addresses the research gap by jointly evaluating the private investment perspective (net private benefit, NPB) and the broader societal perspective (net social benefit, NSB). Through an integrated assessment framework, the analyses compare biomass utilization pathways across a range of technological, regulatory, and market developments. Herein, wheat straw in Germany was selected due to its high theoretical potentials. Under current conditions, BE shows the highest NPB, followed by BECCS, while BCR displays a negative NPB without policy or market adjustments. However, all pathways demonstrate positive NSB when environmental externalities are monetized. Scenario analyses indicate that BECCS can surpass BE in NPB with incentives such as higher carbon removal credit, cost reductions, or improved CO 2 storage infrastructure. BCR becomes NPB-positive under scenarios with either cost reductions or revenue increases. It surpasses BE only when both occur simultaneously but does not exceed BECCS in any scenario. As the energy sector decarbonizes, BCR and BECCS become increasingly competitive. The study emphasizes the need for flexible, context-dependent pathways and robust policy support to ensure that biomass utilization in Germany is viable from both private economic and societal standpoints.
Biomass is a finite yet increasingly demanded renewable energy resource, creating the need to identify utilization pathways that deliver both financial returns and societal benefits. Existing assessments often emphasize economic performance and global warming potential while overlooking environmental externalities and inconsistently accounting for avoided and re- moved CO₂-equivalent (CO₂eq) emissions. These gaps limit their ability to guide pathway- level trade-off assessment and policy design. This study presents a novel framework that integrates techno-economic analysis, life cycle assessment, and monetization of environmental externalities to derive two central metrics: net private benefit (NPB) and net social benefit (NSB). Expressing results per unit of biomass input allows consistent comparison across heterogeneous pathways, such as heat, biochar, and carbon removal credits. The framework distinguishes among types of emissions and re- source use, incorporates multiple environmental impact categories, and links private and so- cietal perspectives to support investment and policy decisions. The framework’s application to miscanthus utilization in Germany compares bioenergy (BE) and biochar carbon removal (BCR). BE yields positive NPB and avoids emissions and re- source use but does not achieve permanent CO₂eq emission removal. BCR removes CO₂eq emissions long-term but results in negative NPB. Both pathways, however, show positive NSB, highlighting synergies and conflicts between private incentives and societal value. Overall, this framework enables a holistic assessment of biomass utilization pathways. By integrating economic and environmental dimensions, standardizing emissions and resource use accounting, and harmonizing metrics, it provides a structured basis for evaluating trade- offs across biomass utilization pathways regarding their private and social benefits.