In the last few years, the existence of a pure number sense has been challenged. Recent studies suggest that numerosity processing is influenced not only by the number of elements in a display but also by continuous magnitudes, such as the size of the elements. The aim of our study was to replicate and extend the findings by Gebuis and Reynvoet, who systematically manipulated different continuous magnitudes either congruently or incongruently with discrete numerosity. We were particularly interested in finding the same pattern of congruency effects and assess its stability and robustness as this pattern indicates a complex influence of continuous magnitudes on numerosity judgements. We did so by showing stimuli of different conditions either in separate blocks or mixed together while participants solved a dot comparison task. Our results are in line with the notion that discrete number and continuous magnitudes are integrated in numerosity judgements by means of a weighing process. Moreover, our findings suggest that this integration is modified by the mode of presentation (blocked vs. mixed).
The interaction of physical and numerical size has been investigated and repeatedly demonstrated in the numerical Stroop task, in which participants compare digits of different physical sizes. It is, however, not entirely clear yet what psychological processes contribute to this interaction. The aim of the present study is to investigate the role of inhibition in the interaction of physical and numerical size, by introducing a novel paradigm that is suitable to elicit inhibition-related event-related potential components. To this end, we combined the go/nogo paradigm with the numerical Stroop task while measuring EEG and reaction times. Participants were presented with Arabic number pairs and had to press a button if the number on one side was numerically larger and they had to refrain from responding if the number on the other side was numerically larger. The physical size of the number pairs was also manipulated, in order to create congruent, neutral, and incongruent trials. Behavioural results confirmed the well-established numerical distance and numerical Stroop effects. Analysis of electrophysiological data revealed the classical go/nogo electrophysiological effects with numerical stimuli, and showed that peak amplitudes were larger for nogo than for go trials on the N2, as well as on the P3 component, on frontal and midline electrodes. When analysing the congruency effects, the peak amplitude of N2 was larger in incongruent trials than in neutral and congruent trials, while there was no evidence of a congruency effect on the P3 component peaks. Further analysis of the electrophysiological data revealed an additional facilitatory effect in the go trials, as well as an additional interference effect in the nogo trials. Taken together, it seems that interference effects are probably resolved by inhibitory processes and that facilitatory effects are affected by different cognitive control processes required by go versus nogo trials.
It has long been debated how humans estimate the numerosity of sets of elements and what role continuous visual properties play in this process. The dot comparison task, in which the more numerous of two dot arrays must be selected, is a dominant method to investigate this phenomenon. It has been shown that the visual properties of the two dot patterns strongly influence the comparison. This influence can be systematically investigated by manipulating visual properties congruently and incongruently with numerosity. However, it remains unclear how learning and prior experience affect the influence of the visual properties. To address this question, we introduced feedback into the classical dot comparison task: during the learning phase, participants in the experimental group received feedback after each trial indicating whether their answer was correct whereas participants in the control group did not. After the learning phase, neither group received feedback. The convex hull of the dot patterns and the average dot diameter were manipulated congruently and incongruently with numerosity. Our results show that feedback had no effect on overall performance. However, when manipulated separately, dot diameter no longer affected performance in the experimental group after the learning phase, but it did in the control group. Moreover, this effect remained visible even when diameter and convex hull were manipulated simultaneously. This pattern of results is consistent with the notion of sensory integration which proposes that weights are assigned to different visual cues and that numerical judgments depend on an additive combination of these weights. We also found a correlation between performance on an arithmetic task and performance on trials in which dot size was manipulated incongruently with numerosity. However, there were no correlations between an inhibition task and performance in the dot comparison task. Taken together, the current results suggest that learning with feedback may affect some visual properties but not others. Future studies should further investigate a wider range of visual properties to examine which of them can be influenced by learning and under what conditions learning occurs.
Introduction: Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) is widely used to study neural processes of behavior, but evaluations of test-retest reliability (TRR) of task-related blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) responses are scarce for many cognitive tasks. Such information is particularly important for longitudinal and intervention research. The ability to learn associations between choices and outcomes across decision stages is crucial for daily behavior. We assessed the measurement reliability of behavioral performance and fMRI BOLD signals during value-based sequential decision making to evaluate the TRR of task-relevant regions for future research on non-invasive brain stimulations. Methods: Twenty healthy adults (22 to 40 years) completed two task-fMRI sessions, at least 2 weeks apart. During scanning, participants performed two variants of a three-stage Markov decision task with conditions varied in temporal contingency (immediate vs. delayed) and magnitude of choice outcomes (high vs. low). Both sessions were conducted under sham tDCS via a focal 3 × 1 montage targeting left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC). TRR was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) with a two-way mixed-effects consistency model for decision performance and task-related fMRI signals at voxel level and summarized in key regions defined by the extended Human Connectome Project atlas (HCPex). Results: Decision performance was lower with delayed than immediate outcomes ( p < 0.001). Higher outcome magnitude improved performance ( p < 0.001). Decision performance increased across learning bins ( p < 0.001). The behavioral TRR was in the moderate to good level (ICC(3,1) = 0.744 for accuracy; ICC(3,1) = 0.788 for reaction time). At the whole-brain level, contrasting brain activities in delayed with immediate condition revealed suprathreshold cluster peaks in several frontal-parietal (e.g., orbitofrontal, bilateral dorsolateral prefrontal, and medial parietal cortices) and striatal regions (e.g., bilateral putamen). Voxel-wise ICCs revealed variable but often moderate-to-good TRR across task-relevant regions, with stronger reliability in several striatal, orbitofrontal, and left dorsolateral prefrontal parcels, and more variable reliability across anterior cingulate and medial prefrontal parcels. Conclusion: These results from a 2-session tDCS sham-sham stimulation study establish the validity of using the three-stage Markov decision task in future studies about intervention effects on the frontal-parietal-striatal network.