Research investigating characteristics that tend to indicate student success in engineering have shown that affective (noncognitive) characteristics such as motivation may have equal to better predictive capabilities than cognitive characteristics such as high school GPA. The mindset of students, whether `fixed' (success is due to inherent intelligence) or `growth' (success is due to effort) can indicate whether a student believes in their ability to solve problems and succeed. Research has shown students tend to move away from a growth mindset and toward a fixed mindset during their first year of study. Our research indicates that introducing open-ended design projects into the curriculum may tend to lessen or eliminate the shift toward fixed mindset. Students assigned open ended, socially relevant engineering projects were compared to students without such projects; students without the open ended experience showed a much greater propensity toward fixed mindset. We hypothesize that these findings may inform introductory engineering and technology courses, including those in high school meant to prepare students for study in STEM areas.
Our research reports on an ongoing study of the impact of entrepreneurial interventions within first-year engineering courses on changes in the mindsets of engineering students. Entrepreneurial mindset in our study is operationally defined as a more growth oriented mindset versus a fixed oriented mindset. This operational definition and an accompanying mindset measurement instrument was developed and validated by Carol Dweck of Stanford University. Based on Dweck's research results we assume a growth mindset is a reasonable surrogate for a student engineer's creative and innovative or entrepreneurial skills. Mindsets of student engineers are benchmarked at the beginning of the freshman year and again at the end of the freshman year, soon after completion of a team based poverty alleviation freshman capstone project. Pre- and post- control samples of freshman engineer mindsets are being collected from similar sized engineering programs at comparable colleges in our geographic vicinity. A pilot study indicated a statistically significant tilt toward a fixed mindset in freshman engineering students compared to a growth mindset observed in an opportunity sample of freshman business students. We are currently tracking engineering students both at the group and at the individual level. Our long-term research goal is to determine how and why engineering course assignments affect a student engineer's entrepreneurial skill set. We hypothesize that a student engineer's creative and innovation skills are in part a learned behavior that is influenced by the student engineer's learning experiences and course assignments. In order to study this phenomenon we are establishing a baseline of the change in engineering student mindset over time. Once we have established this baseline of mindset data, we will then alter interventions to evaluate their differentiated impact on engineer mindset changes.
The number of engineers who are transitioning into environmental sustainability careers is growing, though a gap still exists between the supply and demand. This presents an opportunity for undergraduate engineering students to fulfill the demand as environmental sustainability professionals. This qualitative exploratory study investigated environmental sustainability learning experiences and future career interests in environmental sustainability. The social cognitive theory (SCCT) was utilized as a theoretical lens, exploring undergraduate students’ environmental sustainability interests, related learning experiences and their interest in pursuing a future career in environmental sustainability. Twenty-five undergraduate engineering students in various engineering disciplines were interviewed for this study. Data were analyzed to (1) identify the students’ interest in pursuing a career in environmental sustainability, (2) determine if the students’ interests have changed since they began their undergraduate studies, and (3) explore how learning experiences have impacted the students’ future career choices. The findings posit that exposure to environmental sustainability learning experiences is impactful and plays an important role, impacting the students’ interests in pursuing careers in sustainability. The results reveal that elements such as personal beliefs and salary considerations inspire career choices. This research contributes to addressing the demand for additional working professionals who are prepared to tackle environmental sustainability issues, highlighting the role of learning experiences in shaping students’ career interests.
Female enrollment in engineering in the United States has remained at or below 20% for decades. Enrollment of students from traditionally underrepresented groups has also remained below desired level for years. A systematic understanding of important factors leading to persistence and success in undergraduate engineering programs for female and underrepresented minority students would be very valuable for recruiting, retaining and educating young engineers with diverse perspectives. This paper discusses the significant predictors for retention and academic performance of female engineering students, and reports the difference in comparison with male engineering students. Similar results on the important predictors for retention and performance of underrepresented minority engineering students will also be reported and compared with the ethnic majority students. The findings from this study suggest it is potentially advantageous to develop student success models specific for female or minority engineering student populations, rather than using the same model developed for the whole population. New knowledge obtained through this study will lead to the development of necessary strategies, interventions or programs to help improve retention and academic success of our engineering students.
Beyond the technical skills of engineering, students of any engineering discipline need to develop teamwork knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs) in order to be successful. Various intervention strategies within education systems have been utilized to promote development of teamwork skills and practices in the past. The research team has incorporated the cooperative yet engaging activity based on the commercial board game Pandemic, where students work as a team to play against the game rather than against each other. The activity was introduced to three different engineering departments, highlighting its adoptability. While some discrepancies exist, the qualitative and quantitative data suggest the impact on a department is the same.