Delineating riparian management zones (RMZ) around streams to protect riparian ecological functions is critical during forest management. This study compared the area dedicated to RMZ using the USFS functional-based riparian buffer approach versus individual state-defined riparian buffer allocation strategies along headwater streams across 17 states within the US. The USFS method uses a variable-width riparian buffer that seeks to capture the functions of a riparian area. Our study sought to contrast this USFS method with various state-defined RMZ guidelines. The functional approach delineated the highest percentages of the watershed area around headwater streams in most watersheds, sometimes >20% of forestland, whereas state RMZ guidelines delineated <10% of forestland around headwater streams in many watersheds. Although many state guidelines failed to identify the variable widths of functional riparian areas, some watersheds in the Great Lakes states over-allocated forestland as riparian when compared to a functional riparian delineation. The topographic and forest composition differences observed across the study area were not represented by their respective state RMZ guidelines, and these variables strongly influence the delineation of a functional RMZ.
Riparian buffers implemented to minimize sediment, nutrients, and disturbance impacts on streams during forest operations vary greatly in the degree to which ecological criteria are used in their design. Because most forest operations are concentrated around headwater streams, our primary research objective was to identify a floristically based riparian boundary for headwater streams using plant species composition and indicator species to classify riparian environments distinct from the surrounding upland forest. Within three forested regions of the Northeast US, understory vegetation plots were sampled along perpendicular transects extending from the stream bank into the upland forest. At all sites, species richness was highest adjacent to the stream, decreasing exponentially within 6–12 m from the channel. Species composition closest to the stream was significantly different from all other lateral distances, but identified riparian indicator species were of limited practical use across all sites. However, changes in species richness can serve to identify a riparian area extent up to 6–12 m from headwater streams.
Riparian management zones (RMZs) represent the area surrounding streams that are managed for protecting resources found within a riparian area. They are often established using fixed-width buffers, which may or may not represent the extent of an actual riparian area. This two-pronged study conducted in the Catskill mountains in New York state compares and contrasts the difference in the area dedicated to RMZs along first- and second-order streams between a 100-foot, fixed-width buffer and a variable-width approach using field measurements and regional spatial data derived from high resolution (1 meter) digital terrain model data. The study also examined the opportunity cost of stumpage value for three harvesting scenarios: (1) unlimited harvesting within RMZ; (2) limited harvest restrictions within RMZ; and (3) no harvesting allowed within RMZ. Results indicate a 100-foot, fixed-width buffer could be substituted for a variable-width buffer along first-order streams but could be insufficient to protect riparian functions along second-streams that have wider ravines and floodplains. On average, RMZs along first- and second-order streams account for 8 percent of the timberland area and carry sawtimber volumes of nearly 7 MBF/ac. The residual timber values within RMZs of headwater streams can range from 7–12 percent of the total stumpage revenue.