Structure–property reasoning (SPR) is one of the most important aims of chemistry education but is seldom explicitly taught, and students find structure–property reasoning difficult. This study assessed two design principles for the development of structure–property reasoning in the context of demonstrations: (1) use of a POE task (predict–observe–explain) and (2) use of the domain-specific particle perspective, both to increase student engagement and to scaffold micro-level modeling. The aim of the demonstration series was to teach structure–property reasoning more explicitly to pre-university students (aged 15–16). Demonstrations pertained to the properties of metals, salts and molecular compounds. The SPR instrument was used as a pretest and posttest in order to gain insight into the effects on structure–property reasoning. In addition, one student (Sally) was followed closely to see how her structure–property reasoning evolved throughout the demonstrations. Results show that after the demonstrations students were more aware of the structure models at the micro-level. The students also knew and understood more chemical concepts needed for structure–property reasoning. Sally’s qualitative data additionally showed how she made interesting progress in modeling micro-level chemical structures. As we used conventional demonstrations as a starting point for design, this could well serve as a practical tool for teachers to redesign their existing demonstrations.
1 January 2026 in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
This paper presents a two-phased mixed-method study that investigates Dutch secondary chemistry teachers’ beliefs regarding the implementation of design activities in their chemistry lessons. Despite the various advantages of integrating design within secondary chemistry education, practical design activities do not seem to take place much in secondary school chemistry classrooms. Such curriculum innovations are most effective when guided by teachers’ beliefs. Therefore, it is necessary to investigate chemistry teachers’ beliefs in order to foster effective classroom implementation. However, insight into chemistry teachers’ beliefs about implementation of design in chemistry education is lacking. To fill this gap in literature, a two-phased mixed method strategy was employed. In the first phase, explorative semi-structured interviews uncovered a variety of beliefs held by Dutch chemistry teachers. In the second phase of our study, a quantitative questionnaire with 81 teachers’ responses was employed to measure these beliefs and examine possible relationships with design implementation in chemistry classrooms. Our study reveals that while teachers generally value design as preparation for higher education and view it as a pedagogical approach to teach chemistry content, actual design activities remain rare due to perceived time constraints and curriculum overload. Furthermore, teachers who successfully incorporate design activities, exhibit higher self-efficacy and perceive fewer obstacles than teachers who do not implement a design activity. Teachers who do not implement a design activity frequently cite the abstract nature of the subject as a major constraint. Ultimately, our study highlights an urgent demand for accessible example projects, targeted teacher education and professional development to help teachers effectively bridge the gap between official chemistry standards and practical classroom implementation regarding design activities.