Dropout from engineering studies has been linked to ‘fixed mindset’ beliefs of intelligence as fixed-at-birth that make students more likely to disengage when facing new challenges. In contrast, ‘growth mindset’ beliefs that intelligence can be improved with effort make students more likely to persist when confronting difficulties. This systematic literature review of engineering, education and psychology databases explores the effectiveness of different interventions in developing growth mindset in engineering students, what measures have been used in assessing the effectiveness of these interventions and who has benefited from these interventions, in terms of gender and year of study. We compare interventions by geographical location, intervention type, methodology for assessing mindsets, other topics studied, and effectiveness. The results show a variation in effectiveness among the fifteen included studies. The findings will be useful for educators who want to encourage growth mindset and thereby support the academic success of their students.
20 November 2025 in International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology
University mathematics-support programs rarely test their theoretical foundations against student evidence, particularly in the Global South. This study addresses that gap by analyzing how students’ experiences in Mathematical Thinking Workshops (MTWs) at a South African university confirm, nuance, or challenge assumptions the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD), Action–Process–Object–Schema (APOS) theory, Cognitive Load Theory (CLT), and constructivism. We conducted a qualitative secondary analysis of six focus-group interviews (n = 17), using abductive reflexive thematic analysis and an Assumption–Indicator–Evidence matrix that linked design rationales to student narratives. Student accounts strongly supported ZPD, with facilitation and peer norms fostering psychological safety and risk-taking, while also showing that equitable participation required explicit role-rotation routines. APOS-informed task sequencing enabled coordination across representations but operated recursively, with students calling for planned revisiting sessions to consolidate difficult ideas. CLT claims were affirmed where venue conditions and timing inflated extraneous load, highlighting the need for short debriefs and load-aware logistics. Constructivist activity fostered belonging, confidence, and more social views of mathematics but generated uncertainty when tasks ended without brief closure. We conclude by proposing context-aware refinements to these frameworks and outlining a replicable routine for testing educational theory through student evidence.
This study evaluates whether theory-informed, mathematically focused support can ease the school-to-university transition in an unequal South African STEM context. First-year students could voluntarily attend Mathematical Thinking Workshops (MTWs) grounded in constructivism, the zone of proximal development, APOS theory, and cognitive load theory, providing low-threat, collaborative practice with non-routine, representation-rich tasks. Because attendance was self-selected, we used a quasi-experimental design: participation was modeled from pre-university covariates (school-leaving Mathematics and English grades and standardized university preparedness tests in Mathematics and Quantitative Literacy), and MTW participants were matched to comparable non-participants using nearest-neighbor propensity-score matching. Average treatment effects on the treated were estimated for multiple assessments and for a composite score capturing performance on higher-order items within those assessments. MTW participants outperformed matched peers on early first-semester assessments, especially those containing the most higher-order items, indicating that workshops helped when cognitively demanding tasks first appeared. Effects on later, more distal assessments were positive but attenuated, producing an “early gains, fading effects” pattern. Although estimates were imprecise, benefits appeared largest for students who had scored 70–84% in school-leaving mathematics. Overall, the findings suggest that transitional workshops can deliver timely, assessment-visible gains, although these effects may weaken over time when they are not reinforced or well aligned with later summative assessment.
The Diagnostic Mathematics Information for Student Retention and Success (DMISRS) project was a collaborative project focused on first-year mathematics, which drew together lecturers in South African higher education institutions and other related organisations. Various themes were explored during the annual DMISRS symposia from 2018 to 2022. The project’s culmination was a final DMISRS symposium held in November 2023, which focused on the case studies that examine the sub-projects that have emerged over the years. The symposia have tackled critical themes, including collaborative practices and courses that influence graduation rates, the psychological well-being of students, and innovative solutions in first-year mathematics, such as assessments, performance metrics, blended learning approaches and curriculumdevelopment. The case studies offer valuable narratives of day-to-day interactions, teaching and learning activities, and shared resources or practices in first-year mathematics education experiences. They showcase successes and delve into challenges and their corresponding solutions, providing practical insights that empower the community of practice across diverse higher education institutions and contexts. As a capstone to the DMISRS project’s final symposium, the DMISRS team invited those who contributed case studies to take part in a panel discussion, referred to as the “DMISRS Case Studies Dialogue”, on a range of topics, including their own experiences in setting up and implementing innovations or conducting investigations, and their reflections on the impact of and the legacy of the workdone as part of this project.This paper captures that conversation as a dialogue among the contributorsdone as part of this project. This paper captures that conversation as a dialogue among the contributors.
Admissions policy routinely converts a continuous school-leaving mark into a binary threshold. This study asks whether such a threshold is a defensible admissions rule for first-year mathematics-intensive Bachelor of Science pathways, taking a proposed 80% school-leaving Mathematics cut-off at a research-intensive South African university as the worked case. Using institutional data from first-time entrants in the 2024–2026 cohorts, the study examined school-leaving Mathematics, National Benchmark Test (NBT) in mathematics, and broader pre-university academic measures as predictors of first-semester university mathematics outcomes. Predictive models, threshold analyses, matched-volume admission simulations, differential-prediction tests, and placement analyses were used to distinguish predictive validity from policy usefulness. Within the admitted range, school-leaving Mathematics and NBT Mathematics were related but not interchangeable, and each added information beyond the other. The analyses did not detect a discontinuity at the proposed 80% threshold, and a smooth curve fitted the data better than the binary cut-off models examined. These findings describe the predictive relationship but do not determine the preferred administrative threshold. At the volume implied by the proposed 80% rule, which selected 84.2% of the already-admitted outcome sample, additional pre-university information did not demonstrate a clear increase in passers selected. This finding is specific to that operating point and does not establish the absence of benefit at more selective admission volumes. Differential-prediction analyses also showed that school-leaving Mathematics did not carry the same predictive meaning across population groups. The findings support the predictive relevance of school-leaving Mathematics but do not establish 80% as a uniquely justified admissions threshold. Its policy justification requires explicit consideration of capacity, access, and the consequences of selection errors.