In this paper, we use Nonnegative Matrix Factorization (NMF) and several other state of the art statistical machine learning techniques to provide an in-depth study of university professor evaluations by their students. We specifically use the Kullback–Leibler divergence as our loss function in keeping with the type of the data and extract revealing patterns consistent with the educational objectives underlying the questionnaire design. In particular, the application of our techniques to a dataset gathered at Gazi University in Turkey reveals compelling patterns such as the strong association between the student's seriousness and dedication (measured by attendance) and the kind of scores they tend to assign to the courses and the corresponding professors. Insights emerging from our study suggest that more aspects of students' evaluations should be explored at greater depths.
In this study, we provide simulation-based exploration and characterization of the two most crucial kernel density functionals that play a central role in kernel density estimation, considering the probability density functions that are members of the location-scale family. Kernel density functional estimates are known to rely on the choice of preliminary bandwidth. Normal-scale estimators are commonly used to obtain preliminary bandwidth estimates, with the assumption that the data come from normal distribution. Here, we present an alternative approach, called the Cauchy-scale estimators, to obtain preliminary bandwidth estimates. In this approach, data are assumed to come from a Cauchy distribution. Furthermore, analysis results related to the sampling distribution of bandwidth estimators based on the normal- and Cauchy-scale approaches are presented. As a case study, we provide a comprehensive characterization of different contamination levels with a simulation study constructed for the random samples from normal distributions with various parameters and various contamination levels. The proposed preliminary bandwidth selection shows lower variance in both mixture and contaminated data in our simulations. Besides, functional bandwidth presents results similar to the simulation results in the applications we made on the real data set.
Accurate estimation of the unknown probability density functions of critical variables, such as wind speed—which plays a pivotal role in harnessing clean energy—is essential for various scientific and practical applications. This research conducts a comprehensive comparative analysis of seven distinct bandwidth calculation techniques across various normal distributions, using simulation as the evaluation method in the context of Kernel Density Estimation (KDE). This analysis includes the calculation of the optimal bandwidth and assessment of the performance of these methods with respect to Mean Squared Error (MSE), bias, and the optimal bandwidth value. The findings reveal that among the various bandwidth methods evaluated, the Bandwidth bandwidth-based Cross-Validation (BCV), especially for small sample sizes, consistently provides the closest result to the optimal bandwidth across most of the applied normal distributions. These results provide valuable insights into the selection of optimal bandwidths for accurate and reliable density estimation in the context of normal distributions. Another key aspect of this work is the extension of these methods to wind speed data in a specific region. Monthly wind speed kernel density estimates obtained using all seven bandwidth selection techniques show that Smoothed Cross-Validation (SCV) is suited for this type of real-world data.
1 March 2006 in Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference