Aquaponics is the combined cultivation of fish in aquaculture systems and plants in hydroponic systems. This study aimed to explore and evaluate new aquaponics system designs in Jakarta, Indonesia, in terms of water and nutrient efficiency, and/or profitability. In total, one brackish water system with barramundi and tomato (BW) and three freshwater systems with Nile tilapia, rice, and duckweed (FW + DW), Nile tilapia and rice (FW − DW), and Nile tilapia and tomato (FW-tomato) were investigated using dynamic mathematical models. The results showed an increase of N, P, and water use efficiency by 10%, 18%, and 31%, respectively, in FW-tomato compare to FW − DW. Meanwhile, FW + DW only slightly increased the efficiency but worsened the already negative net present value (NPV) of FW − DW due to the high land prices. The BW system had similar water and nutrient efficiency to FW-tomato, but lower NPV. Profit of the BW and FW-tomato becomes comparable if the hydroponic area in the BW system can be expanded by 35%, or the selling price of tomato or fish in the BW can be increased by 20%. Given the expected growth of both the production of tomatoes and aquaculture in Indonesia, there is potential for further introduction of aquaponics systems in Indonesia.
Bacteria and phytoplankton play an essential role in processing organic and inorganic waste nutrients, making the nutrients reutilized by higher trophic levels in an aquatic food web. Understanding the complex interaction between the microbial food web, nutrients, and cultured animals is crucial to achieving optimum production while minimizing the negative impact of aquaculture production on the environment. Mathematical models have been known as a research tool to conceptualize real systems, beneficial as management and decision‐support tools, and addressing predictive, exploratory, or normative questions. This study is a narrative review of 29 models published from 1984 to 2024 focusing on aquaculture production, particularly the dynamics of microorganisms in fish ponds and their influence on nutrient dynamics and fish growth performance. This study is structured to address several questions: What are the different nutrient inputs considered in farm scale models (FSMs)? What microorganisms are often included in FSMs? How to determine food web dynamics? How are the food web dynamics related to nutrient dynamics and fish growth dynamics? The application of food web dynamics in determining carrying capacity and feed formulation is discussed. Finally, this review discusses the importance of stoichiometry, the limitations of current knowledge, and important considerations for developing or selecting models that are suitable for intended users.