A printed hybrid sensor tag for applications in disposable healthcare and environmental monitoring optimized toward sustainability is presented. Following a systematic Life Cycle Assessment according to ISO 14040:2006 guidelines, the global warming potential associated with various substrate-, electrode-, and sensing materials, as well as manufacturing and end-of-life strategies, are evaluated. Results show that the utilization of bio-based polyethylene and copper inks can minimize the global warming potential most effectively by up to 39% from 42gCO2eq to 25.7gCO2eq per sensor tag. Among manufacturing methods, screen printing coupled with intense pulse light curing emerges as the most eco-efficient combination. Recycling is the most sustainable end-of-life option, although infrastructure challenges impede its full implementation. The silicon sensor chip needed for data communication has been identified as environmental hotspot. This study offers a comprehensive environmental evaluation of sustainable printed sensors and highlights critical challenges and opportunities for the electronics industry, particularly in relation to material selection, recycling strategies, and system-level considerations.
Resistive temperature sensors on two different commercially available uncoated paper substrates have been manufactured using inkjet printing of silver nanoparticles. Their dedication is to be integrated in lightweight materials made from natural fibre-reinforced biopolymers for condition monitoring during the manufacturing process and beyond. The printed sensors have nominal resistances of a few hundred Ohms and kOhms, depending on the roughness and porosity of the respective paper substrate. Compared to previous research in this field, the manufactured sensors were fully characterised and extensively tested as part of this work. Furthermore, the influence of the individual paper characteristics on the electrical properties was studied using white-light interferometry and SEM imaging. All sensors show a good linear temperature dependence, minimal hysteresis and low baseline drift in the temperature range of interest (20 °C–80 °C). In an extended temperature range (−25 °C to 150 °C) and exposed to humidity (0%rH–80%rH) the accuracy and overall quality of the sensors decrease expectedly, still the temperature sensing principle can be exploited depending on the individual application and precision requirements.
Humidity is one of the most relevant physical parameters to sense and control for a wide range of commercial and industrial applications. Consequently, there is continuing demand for the development of innovative and sustainable humidity sensor solutions. Here, the development and characterization of fully additively manufactured, highly sensitive, resistive Chitosan-based humidity sensors on flexible thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) foil as well as on a glass carrier substrate are presented. The sensors unite aspects of sustainability and high performance in a broad humidity range (20 – 90%rH). The humidity response follows an exponential curve progression with relative changes in the resistance per %rH of 6.9 % and 5.7 % for the glass carrier sensor and the TPU sensor, respectively. In absolute values this means that the Chitosan-based sensors are particularly sensitive in the low humidity range with a vast dynamic range (10 times larger compared to commonly used capacitive humidity sensors). The flexible sensor on TPU substrate shows great stability even after repeated bending. In addition, the combination of flexible, and biocompatible materials (TPU and Chitosan) with additive manufacturing technologies makes the sensor particularly sustainable while having great potential for a plethora of biomedical applications.
In a unique approach to develop a “green” solution for in-situ monitoring, low-cost inkjet-printed temperature sensors on paper substrate were fully integrated into natural fiber-reinforced lightweight components for which structural health monitoring is becoming increasingly important. The results showed that the sensors remained functional after the vacuum infusion process; furthermore, the integration of the sensors improved the mechanical integrity and stability of the lightweight parts, as demonstrated by tensile testing. To verify the qualification of the printed sensors for the target application, the samples were exposed to varying temperature and humidity conditions inside of a climate chamber. The sensors showed linear temperature dependence in the temperature range of interest (−20 to 60 °C) with a TCR ranging from 1.576 × 10−3 K−1 to 1.713 × 10−3 K−1. Furthermore, the results from the tests in humid environments indicated that the used paper-based sensors could be made almost insensitive to changes in ambient humidity by embedding them into fiber-reinforced lightweight materials. This study demonstrates the feasibility of fully integrating paper-based printed sensors into lightweight components, which paves the way towards integration of other highly relevant sensing devices, such as strain and humidity sensors, for structural health monitoring of smart, sustainable, and environmentally compatible lightweight composite materials.
With the growing significance of printed sensors on the electronics market, new demands on quality and reproducibility have arisen. While most printing processes on standard substrates (e.g., Polyethylene terephthalate (PET)) are well-defined, the printing on substrates with rather porous, fibrous and rough surfaces (e.g., uncoated paper) contains new challenges. Especially in the case of inkjet-printing and other deposition techniques that require low-viscous nanoparticle inks the solvents and deposition materials might be absorbed, inhibiting the formation of homogeneous conductive layers. As part of this work, the sheet resistance of sintered inkjet-printed conductive silver (Ag-) nanoparticle cross structures on two different, commercially available, uncoated paper substrates using Van-der-Pauw’s method is evaluated. The results are compared to the conductivity of well-studied, white heat stabilised and treated PET foil. While the sheet resistance on PET substrate is highly reproducible and the variations are solely process-dependent, the sheet resistance on uncoated paper depends more on the substrate properties themselves. The results indicate that the achievable conductivity as well as the reproducibility decrease with increasing substrate porosity and fibrousness.
Different conductive bonding strategies for the hybrid integration of flexible, inkjet-printed electronics are investigated. The focus of the present work lies on providing a practical guide comprising standard techniques that are inexpensive, easily implementable and frequently used. A sample set consisting of identical conductive test structures on different paper and plastic substrates was prepared using silver (Ag) nanoparticle ink. The sintered specimens were electrically contacted using soldering, adhesive bonding and crimping. Electrical and mechanical characterization before and after exposing the samples to harsh environmental conditions was performed to evaluate the reliability of the bonding methods. Resistance measurements were done before and after connecting the specimens. Afterwards, 85 °C/85% damp-heat tests and tensile tests were applied. Adhesive bonding appears to be the most suitable and versatile method, as it shows adequate stability on all specimen substrates, especially after exposure to a 85 °C/85% damp-heat test. During exposure to mechanical tensile testing, adhesive bonding proved to be the most stable, and forces up to 12 N could be exerted until breakage of the connection. As a drawback, adhesive bonding showed the highest increase in electrical resistance among the different bonding strategies.