SIMURG_CITIES, is the research and development project that is developed under the main project named as SIMURG: “A performance-based and Sustainability-oriented Integration Model Using Relational database architecture to increase Global competitiveness of Turkish construction industry in industry 5.0 era”, is the relational database model that is currently being developed in a dissertation for performance-based development and assessment of sustainable and sophisticated solutions for the built environment. This study aims to analyze the key performance indicators (KPIs) at «Cities Level» for the smart city concept that is referred to as «Layers» in the master project. KPIs for the concept of a smart city is determined by using the meta-analysis technique. Hence, the three most reputable urban journals issued from 2017 through 2020 are reviewed in this study. In addition to this, models of smart city frameworks/assessment tools/KPIs are reviewed within the context of this paper; environment, economy and governance were found to have domain themes on the urban sustainability according to the literature review. Consequently, efficient and integrated urban management, environmental monitoring and management, public and social services of urban development and sustainability are found to be the most important dimensions in urban and regional planning. SIMURG_CITIES evaluation models for urban projects can use the findings of this paper.
The assessment of urban sustainability and the development of performance-based practical tools for achieving Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are key items for discussion on the public agenda. Despite the urgency of the issues, there is a noticeable lack of studies related to a comprehensive model that could holistically assess sustainability performance at the city level. To address this research gap, SIMURG_CITIES conceptual model, the sub-project of "A Performance-based and Sustainability-oriented Integration Model Using Relational database architecture to increase Global competitiveness of the construction industry" (SIMURG), introduces a system-based methodology to evaluate urban sustainability of different cities. SIMURG_CITIES adopts multiple city layers and their associated key performance indicator (KPI) sets within the built environment dimension of 3D Cartesian system architecture to offer new insights. The purpose of this paper is to develop conceptual models at paradigmatic/philosophical, organizational process, interoperability/integrational, and computational/assessment components, paving the way for practical applications with a relational database model. The model and its relationship with interrelated components are explored by an iterative systems approach using "input-process-output-outcome-impact" (IPO) model and the "people-process-technology" (PPT) methodology. This structure steers the integration of humane, procedural, and technological factors into urban sustainability assessment. In addition, the model could help individuals select ideal urban environments to align with their expectations and to enhance accountability, transparency, and legitimacy in the decision-making processes of public authorities. Through this study, a technology-based approach is found to be effective in assessing urban sustainability and a conceptual framework is established in the contexts of Society 5.0 and urban governance.
Sustainability assessment is one of the basic issues in the agenda of public authorities and it requires practical tools to measure performance in terms of sustainable development goals. Most studies in literature deal with only one dimension of the problem of environmental components of sustainability. These studies discuss entities at only one level (cities, buildings, etc.), and one layer (green, smart, etc.) in selected dimensions. The literature includes no models that claim to provide an integrated assessment of entities’ performance in the 3D Cartesian system. The presently available models do not offer solutions that would be applicable in practice. SIMURG (A performance-based and Sustainability-Oriented Integration Model Using Relational database architecture to increase Global competitiveness of construction industry) proposes using layers and their KPI sets in the assessment process. In addition to philosophical, organisational, integrational, and computational models, this study aims to develop a lean architecture of a relational database model by eliminating ineffective solutions in the practical dimension, i.e. in the computer model. The model can be used by individuals to help them choose built environment whose characteristics match their expectations. Public authorities can utilise the model to increase the level of accountability, transparency, and legitimacy in their decision-making processes.
15 May 2022 in Proceedings of the International Conference of Contemporary Affairs in Architecture and Urbanism-ICCAUA
Today decision-making processes of public authorities for developing sustainable policies, do not support transparency, accountability, and consistency of their decisions. What societies require is a human-centric vision that supports this vision, and the tools that increase the legitimacy of the whole decision-making process. The problem is the lack of these visions and tools that allow the citizens to meet their priorities in their lives with the identities of built environment entities and public authorities to accept/propose suitable projects by using “layers” such as historical/smart/ green/slow/safe, etc. Most of the studies in the literature deal with the sustainability assessment problem at only one environmental dimension of sustainability without considering interactions among the dimensions of 3D Cartesian system and their levels. A paradigmatic model and frame model, which will be used as a guide for developing further conceptual and practical models must be developed from scratch. The conceptual and practical models can only be developed in an iterative process by considering the interactions among these components. In this study, a bottom-up approach in an iterative process was adopted and practiced in the development process of the relationships among the components to propose the above-stated parts of the model of the research.
SIMURG_CITIES, is the research and development project that is developed under the main project named as SIMURG: “A performance-based and Sustainability-oriented Integration Model Using Relational database architecture to increase Global competitiveness of Turkish construction industry in industry 5.0 era”, is the relational database model that is currently being developed in a dissertation for performance-based development and assessment of sustainable and sophisticated solutions for the built environment. This study aims to analyze the key performance indicators (KPIs) at «Cities Level» for the smart city concept that is referred to as «Layers» in the master project. KPIs for the concept of a smart city is determined by using the meta-analysis technique. Hence, the three most reputable urban journals issued from 2017 through 2020 are reviewed in this study. In addition to this, models of smart city frameworks/assessment tools/KPIs are reviewed within the context of this paper; environment, economy and governance were found to have domain themes on the urban sustainability according to the literature review. Consequently, efficient and integrated urban management, environmental monitoring and management, public and social services of urban development and sustainability are found to be the most important dimensions in urban and regional planning. SIMURG_CITIES evaluation models for urban projects can use the findings of this paper.