While metabarcoding and metagenomic approaches are increasingly popular, questions remain about how best to analyse and taxonomically characterize the sequence data produced by such methods. Due to a lack of software infrastructure, important reference sequence curation steps are often ignored. We present MetaCurator, a software package designed for automated reference sequence curation and highly generalizable across markers and study systems. MetaCurator contains two signature tools. IterRazor utilizes profile hidden Markov models and an iterative search framework to exhaustively identify and extract the precise marker of interest from available references. DerepByTaxonomy dereplicates sequences using a taxonomically aware approach, removing duplicates only when they belong to the same taxon. This is important for highly conserved markers, such as plant rbcL and trnL, which often display no sequence divergence across taxa, even at the genus level. Using MetaCurator, we produced reference sequence databases for a popular arthropod COI marker as well as four plant barcoding markers, trnL, rbcL, ITS2 and trnH. In comparing these databases to those produced by recent and comparable studies, we show that the Metacurator pipeline exhibits greater sensitivity during sequence extraction, especially for poorly conserved markers. Further, database taxonomic richness was not decreased following sequence dereplication, as observed in previous studies. MetaCurator is supported on OSX and Linux and is freely available under a GPL v3.0 license at https://github.com/RTRichar/MetaCurator. The reference databases produced in this work, and the commands used for curation, are available at https://github.com/RTRichar/MetabarcodeDBsV2.
A present goal of the Conservation Reserve Program (CRP) is to manage land in agricultural landscapes to increase pollinator abundance and diversity. CP42, or the pollinator seed mix, is planted and managed to support foraging pollinators with blooming flowers present at all points in the foraging season. This high-quality habitat provides an excellent opportunity to study honey bee nutrition and determine whether honey bees located near CRP sites use known resources included in planting seed mixes. This study aims to highlight the primary sources of honey bee forage in the northern Midwest as well as to assess honey bee utilization of the floral resources provided by the pollinator seed mix used for CRP plantings. We received pollen samples collected using pollen traps by beekeepers in Ohio, South Dakota, Indiana, Illinois, and Michigan. Metabarcoding methods were used to identify and quantify pollen collected at different points in the season. The results indicate that honey bees frequently used major mass flowering resources such as Glycine, Trifolium, and Symphiotrichum throughout the season. In addition, flowers included in the CRP pollinator seed mix were used modestly. These results have implications for pollinator seed mix design.
10 March 2022 in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Spring is an essential time for honey bee foraging in temperate climates. This is a period of increased brood rearing supporting colony growth and demands access to high-quality pollen and nectar resources. With the expansion of urban and agricultural landscapes, the availability of pollen and nectar producing flowers is declining in many areas. We aim to determine how patterns of spring pollen and nectar foraging differ between colonies surrounded by varying degrees of urban and agricultural intensity, as well as to assess the potential for nectar sampling to serve as a proxy for pollen collection. Thirteen apiaries in Central Ohio, along a gradient of urban and agricultural intensity, were monitored in spring of 2019 through the periodic collection of pollen and nectar samples and continuous colony weight monitoring. We found that spring honey bees in urban and agricultural areas gain comparable amounts of weight and use similar spring resources. Foraging was heavily focused on flowering trees and shrubs including Malus (apple), Salix (willow), and Prunus (cherry), until the beginning of clover bloom (Trifolium spp.). We also identified differences in pollen and nectar foraging within colonies, with nectar containing fewer species collected more evenly than matched pollen samples. These results demonstrate that honey bees in both agricultural and urban environments exhibit similar foraging patterns during the spring, and that plant species important for nectar collection are substantially different from plants important for pollen foraging, though limitations in nectar collection hinder our ability to draw definitive comparisons of pollen and nectar foraging in this region.