The sugarcane (Saccharum spp. L.) mechanical harvesting system leaves a large amount of straw mulch on the soil surface. The straw mulch may affect soil conditions, root regrowth, and sugarcane yield. Thus, this study assessed the response of sugarcane root system growth and stalk yield to different rates of straw removal. An experiment was conducted in a Rhodic Kandiudox with sand clay loam texture to test the impact of four rates of straw removal: no removal (18.9 Mg ha−1 of dry mass); moderate removal (8.7 Mg ha−1); high removal (4.2 Mg ha−1) and total removal on sugarcane root system and stalk yield. Higher concentrations of roots (60%) were found in the first 40 cm of soil. Moderate straw removal resulted in higher root mass (3.6 Mg ha−1) and stalk production (23 Mg ha−1 of dry mass). However, no straw removal reduced root mass by 20% (105 Mg ha−1). Through regression analysis, it was estimated that retaining between 8.5 and 13 Mg ha−1 of straw resulted in the highest root mass and stalk yield. Managing straw removal to retain a moderate amount enables producers to sustain suitable soil conditions for sugarcane root growth and stalk production while providing straw for industrial use.
Sugarcane straw is a potential feedstock to increase bioenergy production. However, leaving straw on the soil surface is important to sustaining soil organic matter (SOM). We conducted a field experiment to evaluate the impacts of two years of straw removal on SOM in a sugarcane area – on an Eutric Nitisol in south-eastern Brazil – with low straw production (7 Mg ha–1). The experiment was a randomised complete block design (four blocks) with four rates of straw removal: (i) no removal, (ii) medium removal, (iii) high removal and (iv) total removal. We evaluated straw decomposition, soil carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) stock (0–30 cm), labile C, and microbial biomass C and N (0–10 cm). Increases in the straw removal rates reduced decomposition, with 30–42% of the initial straw amount remaining on the soil after one year (first year) and 33–38% remaining at the end of the second year. During the first year, no effect was found on soil C (8 kg m–2) and N (0.7 kg m–2) stocks; however, during the second year, total straw removal reduced soil C stock by 10% (0–30 cm) compared with no straw removal. Straw removal rates negatively affected the labile C (6–10% and 20–25%, first and second year respectively) and microbial C (correspondingly 10–15% and 21–27%). Microbial N was not altered in the first year, but decreased 26% due to straw maintenance (no removal) during the second year. Total straw removal decreased the C management index (CMI) by 15% (first year) compared with no straw removal. However, during the second year, all rates of straw removal decreased the CMI: by 15% for medium, 22% for high and 26% for total removal. Our findings indicate that any straw removal in areas with low straw production negatively affects SOM, initially through reduction in labile C pools. Although slight impacts on soil C and N stock were detected, reduction in straw-derived inputs stimulates microbial utilisation of soil C pools, and consequently reduces SOM over time.