Metal Manipulation: Reducing the grain size below 100 micrometers can vastly improve the properties of a metal. However, these nanocrystalline metals are not thermally stable; at elevated temperatures the grains will grow and merge. Alloying with a second metal to slow grain growth can slow down this process, which has shown some success on a trial-and-error basis.
Chookajorn
et al. (p. 951 ; see the Perspective by Weertman ) now provide a theoretical framework to create stability maps to identify potential alloys with the greatest thermal stability. For tungsten, counterintuitively, the theory suggests that atoms with the largest size differential or lowest solubility are not the best alloying choice. Indeed, an alloy of tungsten and titanium was processed more easily than pure nanocrystalline tungsten and also showed better stability at high temperatures.
Nanocrystalline W powders with ∼20 nm average grain size are produced by high-energy ball milling and exposed to a target consolidation temperature of 1100 °C. After 1 week, unalloyed W exhibits substantial grain growth, whereas a W alloy with 20 at.% Ti retains its nanoscale structure. A heterogeneous distribution of Ti is observed by independent characterization methods, including scanning transmission electron microscopy, energy dispersive spectroscopy and atom probe tomography. This heterogeneous solute distribution is different from the expected homogeneous solid solution based on bulk W–Ti phase diagrams. Using a Monte Carlo simulation that includes the possibility of grain boundary segregation and allows grain boundaries as potential equilibrium states, a complex nanoscale structure of Ti around W-rich crystallites is explicitly reproduced. This simulated structure has both grain size and extrema in local Ti content in line with the experimental observations.United States. Defense Threat Reduction Agency (Grant No. HDTRA1-11-1-0062)United States. Army Research Office (Grant No. W911NF-09-1-0422
A Monte Carlo simulation method is used to study the energetics and configuration of binary alloys when grain boundary states are included as potential equilibrium features. For certain sets of alloy properties, a nanostructured grain assembly is found to be the most energetically favorable state, and is stabilized by grain boundary segregation of solute. The conditions for stability against grain coarsening and the ``grain boundary energy'' requirement are clarified, with emphasis on the closed system conditions that prevail in nanostructured alloys. Two thermodynamic parameters, the grain boundary area potential and the grain boundary formation energy, are quantitatively disentangled and shown to differently reflect grain stability and the energy state of interfaces. These discussions provide insights on how alloying can be used to actively manipulate nanocrystalline grain sizes.
The instability of nanocrystalline materials against both grain growth and bulk phase separation is a principal challenge in their production and usage. This article reviews the thermodynamic stabilization of nanocrystalline structures by alloying, where a nanocrystalline state is considered to be stable if the nanostructure has the lowest free energy available to the alloy system, such that it is stable both against grain growth and the formation of bulk second phases. The thermodynamic accessibility of nanocrystalline structures in the alloy phase space introduces configurational degrees of freedom both at the atomic scale of the grain boundary structure and at the mesoscale level of the grains and grain boundary topology, which should be considered when identifying the equilibrium state. This article presents a survey of the kinds of thermodynamic models and simulations that have been developed to search for equilibrium nanocrystalline states. The review emphasizes the utility of Monte Carlo simulations to assess the thermodynamic stability of nanocrystalline states, including methods that have been proposed to account for degrees of freedom at both the atomic and grain scales. Although atomic scale simulations provide detailed segregation energetic information, the topological degrees of freedom in nanoscale polycrystals seem to be more critical considerations in the free energy description for identifying whether a nanocrystalline state is stable, and these are better addressed with mesoscale lattice-based simulation methods. A variety of interesting new nanostructural alloy states awaits further exploration by computational methods.