To evaluate the chemical behavior and the health impact of welding fumes (WF), a complex and heterogeneous mixture of particulate metal oxides, two certified reference materials (CRMs) were tested: mild steel WF (MSWF-1) and stainless steel WF (SSWF-1). We determined their total chemical composition, their solubility, and their oxidative potential in a phosphate buffer (PB) solution under physiological conditions (pH 7.4 and 37 °C). The oxidative potential (OPDTT) of WF CRMs was evaluated using an acellular method by following the dithiothreitol (DTT) consumption rate (µmol DTT L−1 min−1). Pure metal salts present in the PB soluble fraction of the WF CRMs were tested individually at equivalent molarity to estimate their specific contribution to the total OPDTT. The metal composition of MSWF-1 consisted mainly of Fe, Zn, Mn, and Cu and the SSWF-1 composition consisted mainly of Fe, Mn, Cr, Ni, Cu, and Zn, in diminishing order. The metal PB solubility decreased from Cu (11%) to Fe (approximately 0.2%) for MSWF-1 and from Mn (9%) to Fe (<1%) for SSWF-1. The total OPDTT of SSWF-1 is 2.2 times the OPDTT of MSWF-1 due to the difference in oxidative capacity of soluble transition metals. Cu (II) and Mn (II) are the most sensitive towards DTT while Cr (VI), Fe (III), and Zn (II) are barely reactive, even at higher concentrations. The OPDTT measured for both WF CRMs extracts compare well with simulated extracts containing the main metals at their respective PB-soluble concentrations. The most soluble transition metals in the simulated extract, Mn (II) and Cu (II), were the main contributors to OPDTT in WF CRMs extracts. Mn (II), Cu (II), and Ni (II) might enhance the DTT oxidation by a redox catalytic reaction. However, summing the main individual soluble metal DTT response induces a large overestimation probably linked to modifications in the speciation of various metals when mixed. The complexation of metals with different ligands present in solution and the interaction between metals in the PB-soluble fraction are important phenomena that can influence OPDTT depletion and therefore the potential health effect of inhaled WF.
21 March 2024 in Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts
Inhalation of welding fumes (WFs) containing high levels of transition metals (Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni…) is associated with numerous health effects including oxidative stress. However, the measurements of the oxidative potential (OP) and bioaccessibility of WF transition metals depend on several physicochemical parameters and may be subject to several experimental artifacts. In this work, we investigated the influence of the experimental conditions that may affect the bioaccessibility of transition metals and their OP on stainless-steel WF extracts. WFs were produced using a generation bench and sampled on filters. The soluble fraction of the metals was analysed. Two different extraction fluids mimicking physiological pulmonary conditions were studied: phosphate buffer and Hatch's solution. Three extraction times were tested to determine the optimal time for a significant OPDTT using the dithiothreitol (DTT) method. The storage conditions of WFs after filter sampling such as duration, temperature and atmospheric conditions were investigated. The results indicate that experimental conditions can significantly affect the OPDTT and metal bioaccessibility analyses. Cr, Cu and Ni show higher solubility in Hatch's solution than in the phosphate buffer. Mn is highly sensitive to DTT and shows close solubility in the two fluids. An extraction time of 0.5 h in phosphate buffer allows a better sensitivity to OPDTT, probably by limiting complexations, interactions between metals and precipitation. Storage time and temperature can influence the physical or chemical evolution of the WFs, which can affect their OPDTT and Mn solubility. However, storage under N2(g) limits these changes. On-line measurements of OPDTT could provide an alternative to filter sampling to overcome these artifacts.
L’inhalation des fumées de soudage (FS) contenant des niveaux élevés en métaux de transition (Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni…) est liée à de nombreux effets sanitaires. Dans ce travail de thèse, en vue d’optimiser les protocoles opératoires, j’ai réalisé une étude paramétrique sur les facteurs expérimentaux influençant la bioaccessibilité des métaux de transition et le potentiel oxydant (PO) d’extraits de fumées produites en laboratoire lors du soudage d’acier doux et inox sur un banc de génération contrôlée. Les paramètres tels que le milieu et la durée d’extraction des FS, le choix du test chimique de mesure du PO, les conditions de vieillissement des FS avant analyse et la nature des principaux métaux extraits, en particulier leur fraction soluble dans le tampon phosphate (0,1 mol L-1, 37°C, pH 7,4), ont montré un effet significatif sur les mesures de leur bioaccessibilité et du PO. Mn (II) et Cu (II) sont les éléments les plus solubles et, avec Ni(II), les principaux contributeurs au PO mesuré par la méthode dithiothréitol (PODTT). Mn est le métal dont le comportement est le plus affecté par le vieillissement des FS. La spéciation des métaux apparaît comme un paramètre-clé expliquant la variation de la bioaccessibilité des métaux et les PODTT des extraits de FS. A partir de ces résultats, la méthode sélectionnée a consisté à prélever les FS sur des filtres en PVC, les extraire dans une solution tampon phosphate durant 30 minutes puis déterminer le PO des extraits par la méthode DTT. Ce protocole a servi de base à la conception et au dimensionnement d’un prototype de prélèvement et d’analyse « on-line » du PODTT des FS. Le dispositif est composé d’un système de prélèvement des particules de FS, d’une cellule de réaction et d’un système de détection spectrophotométrique. Les premiers essais du système de détection ont montré une grande sensibilité et une bonne cohérence avec la littérature et les mesures effectuées avec un lecteur de microplaques sur des échantillons comparables. Des investigations complémentaires sont nécessaires pour comprendre l’influence de la phase gazeuse et de la fraction insoluble des FS sur le PO. Le système « on-line » du PO facilitera la surveillance sanitaire des professionnels exposés à des particules riches en métaux oxydants comme les FS.