Accurate predictions in forest operations can be used towards effective planning, costing, and maximizing the productivity of machines in mechanised cut-to-length (CTL) harvesting. There is a general and substantial gap in forwarder productivity data available for pine sawtimber in South Africa at present, and as the number of product assortments being harvested increase there is a need for more work to quantify the effects of extracting products of different dimensions. The aim of this study was to calculate the time consumption and productivity of two models of Ponsse forwarders (15 t and 20 t capacity) to consider and compare the effects of multiple variables including machine capabilities, product assortment, load size, extraction distance and fuel consumption. Productivity averaged at 34.08 m3 per productive machine hour excluding delays longer than one minute (PMH1) for the smaller machine, and 55.94 m3/PMH1 for the larger machine. Productivity and average log volume were strongly positively correlated. Regression models were created for each machine where load volume and extraction distance were both significant factors for predicting productivity. Average fuel consumption of the smaller machine was 15.55 l/PMH1 and 0.47 l/m3, and 20.57 l/PMH1 and 0.43 l/m3 for the larger machine. The product with the largest volume was found to require the least fuel per m3. The models developed could aid in predicting system productivity and potentially carbon emissions under similar conditions in a South African context of industrial plantation forestry.
18 April 2018 in International Journal of Forest Engineering
With the emergence of excavator-based harvesters in cut-to-length CTL operations as a potential alternative to purpose-built harvesters, a debate has been opened as to which machine type is the most suitable in the forestry environment. A mechanized Eucalyptus pulpwood CTL operation, was observed to determine the effect of slope on harvester productivity and cost. A 2 × 2 factorial design with two treatments (machine type) against slope and individual tree volume as factors was developed. Two machine types were studied, an excavator-based harvester (Volvo EC210BF), and a purpose-built harvester (TimberPro TL725B), both fitted with Maskiner SP 591 LX harvester heads. A single operator with significant experience on both machines was used throughout the study. The machines worked on a range of slopes, from level to 50% in two separate corridors containing trees of similar volume and form. Continuous slope data was derived using large footprint light detection and ranging (LiDAR) data of the area. Calculations were carried out on each machine to determine which machine was more cost-effective. The productivity of the excavator based harvester decreased by 0.048 m3PMH−1 for every 1% increase in slope, while the productivity of the purpose-built harvester was constant across slope. While the purpose-built harvester was found to have a higher mean productivity the excavator-based harvester was more economical. This suggests that, in terms of economics the excavator-based harvester was more suitable across the conditions encountered in this study.
1 March 2019 in International Journal of Forest Engineering
In this study, a South African pine sawtimber mechanized cut-to-length harvesting operation was analyzed with the objective of modelling productivity development learning curves of beginner operators in both clear-felling and thinning operations. Trainee operators were selected based on the results of an assortment of psychometric testing and subsequently completed several harvester simulator tests. On average, a trainee operator would start at aperformance level (PL) of 60% lower than the population’s mean test time per test (PTmean) and end with a PL of 22% higher than the PTmean. Furthermore, when the PL of an average simulator trainee was measured over a period of 8.4 days or 25.2 tests (three tests per day), the operator’s PL was improved by 200%. Following sufficient simulator training, the operators began working in-field. Thinning operators worked with an average tree size of 0.18 m3, starting at a productivity of 13.71 m3 per productive machine hour excluding delays longer than 5 minutes (PMH5) at month one and increasing their productivity to 38.96 m3·PMH5−1 by the end of month 12. Clear-felling operators worked with an average tree size of 0.54 m3, starting at a productivity of 27.56 m3·PMH5−1 at month one and increased their productivity to 43.75 m3·PMH5−1 by the end of month 12. Ultimately, the thinning and clear-fell operators reached the end of their learning curves after an average of 9 and 6.5 months, and increased their productivity performances by 218% and 104%, respectively. These findings suggest acceptable learning periods and performance increases for beginner harvester operators.
18 June 2010 in International Journal of Forest Engineering
Time studies were carried out on a stump-to-mill multi-stem Eucalyptus harvesting and transport operation in Zululand, South Africa in 2007. A simulation model (System 1) of this system was subsequently built using a commercial simulation software package (Arena 9) and data from the time studies incorporated into the model. Following this, two hypothetical stump -to-mill multi-stem models (Systems 2 and 3) were built using Arena 9 and parameterized input data. All models were found to adequately represent reality. Simulated harvesting system balance was improved through normalization of machine utilization in Systems 2 and 3. Production improvements were predicted with simulated timber production per month increasing by 31.1% and 30.8%, from System 1 with three trucks, to System 2 with four trucks, and System 3 with four trucks, respectively. Cost reduction was predicted, with the cost per unit of timber decreasing by 12.5% and 4.1%, from System 1 with three trucks, to System 2 with four trucks and System 3 with four trucks, respectively. Beneficial operational techniques were also confirmed using the simulation models. In the studied conditions delimbing and debarking of full trees into tree lengths at roadside with delimber-debarkers before cross-cutting and loading with a slasher was predicted to be $0.65/m3 cheaper than delimbing, debarking, and cross-cutting full trees into pulpwood with processors at the landing and then loading with a loader. Usability of Arena 9 in modeling forest harvesting operations was concluded as acceptable, but required detailed background logic inclusion.
1 July 2004 in The Southern African Forestry Journal
Shorthaul transport, also known as secondary intermediate transport (SIT), is a feature of pulpwood transport in South Africa. SIT is an additional transport phase within traditional secondary transport. It originates at roadside landing or depot and terminates at another depot, rail siding or merchandising area (not the final destination). The reason for the inclusion of SIT is identified as the result of the poor and steady decline of forest road conditions to the extent that highway type vehicles are unable to reach roadside landings. This necessitates the use of intermediate storage sites, from where timber is once again loaded and transported to its final destination. A network analysis model, assisted by newly developed and industry accepted terminology, and pixel-based geographic information system (GIS) were combined to analyse various transport scenarios within three study areas in the KwaZulu/Natal Midlands of South Africa, employing SIT on poor, high-density forest road networks. The simple pixel-based GIS contained information on the forest road network, surface cover and slope. The results of the economic analysis highlighted the need for the reduction of road network densities and for the improvement of the remaining network. This would eliminate the need for extended primary transport and allow the use of highway vehicles transporting from compartment roadside to and past plantation exits. Results show the average annual cost penalty to the industry, by maintaining SIT and related transport, to be R43.25 million or R8.24/m3. SIT accounts for between 10 and 15% of the total delivered cost of round wood pulpwood
18 June 2003 in International Journal of Forest Engineering
Shorthaul transport, known as secondary intermediate transport (SIT), is an additional transport phase within traditional secondary transport in South Africa. It originates at roadside landing or depot and terminates at another depot or rail siding (not the final destination). The use of SIT is forced by poor and steadily declining forest road conditions, to the extent that highway type vehicles are unable to reach roadside landings. This necessitates the use of intermediate storage sites, from which the timber is once again loaded and transported to its final destination. A network analysis model and grid cell-based geographic information system were combined to analyse the various transport scenarios within three study areas in the KwaZulu/Natal Midlands of South Africa, employing SIT on poor, high-density forest road networks. Results show the South African forest industry’s average annual transportation cost penalty, by maintaining SIT, to be $US 4.32 million or $US 0.82/m3 over the cost of transportation over an improved road network using only secondary terminal transport. This cost differential does not account for the cost of upgrades required to eliminate the need for SIT. However a net present value cost analysis of the inclusion of road upgrade costs versus the average annual transportation cost savings and increased forest yield from decommissioned roads, maintains a positive financial benefit. Economic analysis highlighted the need for reduced road network densities and for improvement of the remaining network. This would eliminate extended primary transport, multiple loading, unloading and storage by allowing highway vehicles to transport timber from compartment roadside to its final destination.