Spudcan punch-through during installation and preloading process is one of the key concerns for the jack-up industry. This incident occurs in layered deposits, with new design approaches for spudcan penetration in sand-over-clay deposits reported recently. This paper reports a novel design approach for spudcan penetration in stiff-over-soft clay deposits. Large-deformation finite element (LDFE) analyses were carried out using the Coupled Eulerian–Lagrangian (CEL) approach. The clay was modelled using the extended elastic – perfectly plastic Tresca soil model allowing strain softening and rate dependency of the undrained shear strength. A detailed parametric study was undertaken, varying the strength ratio between bottom and top soil layers, the thickness of the top layer relative to the spudcan diameter, and degree of nonhomogeneity of the bottom layer. Existing data from centrifuge model tests were first used to validate the LDFE results, and then the measured and computed datasets were used to develop the formulas in the proposed design approach. The approach accounts for the soil plug in the bottom layer, and the corresponding additional resistance. Where there is the potential for punch-through, the approach provides estimations of the depth and bearing capacity at punch-through, the bearing capacity at the stiff–soft layer interface, and the bearing capacity in the bottom layer. Comparison shows that the punch-through method suggested in ISO standard 19905-1 provides a conservative estimate of the bearing capacity at punch-through, with guidelines provided to improve the method.
1 July 2014 in Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering
This paper reports the results from numerical modeling of spudcan deep penetration through three-layer clays. Two typical seabed strength profiles commonly encountered in the field, and identified as critical for potential punch-through failure, were considered: (1) uniform stiff-soft-stiff clay and (2) nonuniform clay with an interbedded stiff clay layer. Three-dimensional large deformation finite-element (LDFE) analyses were carried out with and without simulating strain softening and strain rate dependency of the shear strength. The results were compared with previously published LDFE results and centrifuge test data. A detailed parametric study was undertaken, varying the relevant range of layer thicknesses (relative to the spudcan diameter), strength ratios, normalized strength, and strength nonhomogeneity. Punch-through and rapid leg penetration (for stiff-over-soft) and squeezing (for the reverse) were demonstrated by the penetration resistance profiles and associated soil failure mechanisms. The results emphasized that the resistance profile from a spudcan continuous penetration in a three-layer sediment (e.g., stiff-soft-stiff) may be significantly different from the combined profiles resulting from two separate analyses on first-second layers and second-third layers, even if an appropriate depth factor is accounted for. For uniform stiff-soft-stiff clays, the presence of the bottom stiff clay layer within a short distance of one diameter affected spudcan bearing response in the top layer and suppressed the potential for punch-through failure (apart from rapid leg run for and ). A trapped soil plug beneath the advancing spudcan, following penetration of the top stiff layer, caused the bottom stiff layer to be sensed earlier and led to enhancement of the limiting squeezing depth. For nonuniform clay with an interbedded stiff layer, spudcan bearing response was dominated by squeezing (with limiting squeezing depth of approximately ) in the top soft layer and potential punch-through and rapid leg run (for and ) in the middle and bottom layers. In contrast to ISO recommendations, the soft soils in between the advancing spudcan base and the stronger layer did not squeeze out completely. Instead, some of the trapped material was forced into the underlying stronger layer. Punch-through distance was found to reduce significantly with increasing positive strength gradient of the bottom layer.
1 March 2018 in Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering
The paper presents a new mechanism-based two-step approach for assessing spudcan penetration resistance in three-layer stiff-soft-stiff clay sediments. An alternative approach is also proposed, establishing a direct correlation between spudcan and cone penetration resistances. The approaches are developed based on the results from a parametric study through large-deformation finite-element analyses and validated against centrifuge test data and a case history. These can be taken as a “top-down” approach. The bearing capacities are evaluated at the seabed, at the depth of maximum bearing capacity in the first (stiff) layer, at the depth of triggering squeezing in the second (soft) layer, and at the second–third layer interface successively, followed by the estimation of the penetration resistance profile in the third (stiff) layer. For the mechanism-based approach, design formulae are also proposed for assessing the limiting cavity depth, variation of the soil plug height, and equivalent undrained shear strength of the second layer that accounts for the effect of the third layer. The depth of triggering squeezing in the second layer is estimated through an iterative approach to incorporate the effect of the soil plug trapped beneath the advancing spudcan, which leads to earlier squeezing. For the alternative approach, design correlations are established between cone tip and spudcan penetration resistances. A direct comparison between the estimated profiles using the proposed design approaches and the “bottom-up” approach recommended in the current international design standard confirms the benefit of using the former.