Many accounts of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) imply that the condition's behavioural ‘symptoms’ are direct reflexes of underlying deficits. In doing so, however, they invariably overlook the social contexts in which symptomatic behaviours occur and are identified as pathological. This study addresses this issue, using conversation analysis (CA) to examine the emergence of inflexibility, a behavioural trait symptomatic of ASD, during play involving an adult and diagnosed child. We argue that ‘inflexibility’ is the product of the child's strategic attempts to retain control over the unfolding interaction, within a context where such attempts breach normative expectations about adult–child play. Furthermore, it demonstrates that the adult does not resist these attempts, on occasion even explicitly providing opportunity for subsequent inflexibility. This challenges the assumption that ASD's behavioural profile solely represents the endpoint of underlying deficit, and demonstrates how ‘non-impaired’ speakers can be implicated in the manifestation of symptomatic behaviours.
27 March 2012 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
In the UK, exclusions from school because of behaviour problems usually occur when other alternatives have proved unsuccessful. There is some evidence to suggest that behaviour problems and resulting school exclusions are associated with language impairment. In older children who are permanently excluded, expressive rather than receptive language impairment is more common and this is associated with increased rates of emotional problems (Ripley and Yuill, 2005). The language abilities of secondary age pupils at risk of permanent school exclusion who are still in mainstream educational provision have not yet been a focus of study. Fifteen pupils attending a mainstream secondary school located in an area of socio-economic deprivation were studied. All the pupils were at risk of permanent exclusion owing to significant behaviour problems. Measures of language and behaviour identified language difficulties in 10 of the 15 pupils, where five of these pupils had significant and severe language difficulties. In contrast, the remaining five pupils showed age-appropriate or typical language abilities. Although differences were identified in language abilities, severe behaviour problems were found in both the pupils with language difficulties and those with age-appropriate language. Mixed receptive-expressive language difficulties were more common than expressive only difficulties but these were not associated with a particular type of behaviour problem. For a high proportion of secondary age pupils at risk of permanent school exclusion, language difficulties are a factor in their behaviour problems and school exclusion. The preliminary findings are discussed with reference to the relationship between language impairment and behaviour problems, the criteria for defining language impairment in this population, the need for further research and potential implications for education and speech and language therapy.
6 September 2015 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders