Purpose: To compare corneal tomography and its statistical uncertainty for measurements obtained by three clinically used corneal tomographers: A Scheimpflug camera (Pentacam HR), a swept source optical coherence tomography system (CASIA SS-1000), and Placido ring imaging (TMS-5). Material and Methods: Repeated measurements with all three devices on 34 normal eyes were used to estimate the repeatability, precision, and mean values of corneal elevation and pachymetry within 8 mm diameter. The repeatability (standard deviation) was calculated for each data point of the corneal elevation data-maps of anterior and posterior cornea as well as for the pachymetry data-maps. Uncertainty on the position of the eye at each measurement might contribute to the differences between elevation data-maps. To take this into account, we defined the precision as the standard deviation for the elevation data-maps of anterior and posterior cornea after correction of misalignment-effects (rotation, translation). The mean elevation and pachymetry data-maps were fitted with Zernike polynomials for interdevice-comparison. Results: Pentacam HR offered the best repeatability and precision for the anterior corneal elevation (<3 and <1.6 μm, respectively). CASIA SS-1000 offered good repeatability and precision with high resolution for posterior corneal elevation, and the best repeatability for pachymetry (<3 μm). TMS-5 measured anterior elevation with similar repeatability to CASIA SS-1000 (<6 μm). The data-maps of the three tomographers could not be used interchangeably. The largest differences were observed for pachymetry and posterior corneal elevation data-maps. Conclusions: Misalignment limited the repeatability of TMS-5 and Pentacam HR, but had little influence on the repeatability of CASIA SS-1000.
To discuss the impact of intraocular lens-(IOL)-power, IOL-thickness, IOL-shape, corneal power and effective lens position (ELP) on the distance between the anterior IOL vertex (ALP) of a thick IOL and the ELP of its thin lens equivalent. We calculated the ALP of a thick IOL in a model eye, which results in the same focal plane as a thin IOL placed at the ELP using paraxial approximation. The model eye included IOL-power (P), ELP, IOL-thickness (Th), IOL-shape-factor (X), and corneal power (DC). The initial values were P = 10 D (diopter: 1 D = 1 m-1), 20 D, 30 D, Th = 0.9 mm, ELP = 5 mm, X = 0, DC = 43 D. The difference between ALP and the ELP was illustrated as a function of each of the model parameters. The ALP of a thick lens has to be placed in front of the ELP for P>0 IOLs to achieve the same optical effect as the thin lens equivalent. The difference ALP-ELP for the initial values is -0.57 mm. Minus power IOLs (ALP-ELP = -0.07 mm, for IOL-power = -5 D) and convex-concave IOLs (ALP-ELP = -0.16 mm, for X = 1) have to be placed further posterior. The corneal power and ELP have less influence, but corneal power cannot be neglected. The distance between ELP and ALP primarily depends on IOL-power, IOL-thickness, and shape-factor.
The capabilities of a weighted least squares approach for the optimization of the intraocular lens (IOL) constants for the Haigis formula are studied in comparison to an ordinary least squares approach. The weights are set to the inverse variances of the effective optical anterior chamber depth. The effect of random measurement noise is simulated 100000 times using data from N = 69 cataract patients and the measurement uncertainty of two different biometers. A second, independent data set (N = 33) is used to show the differences that can be expected between both methods. The weighted least squares formalism reduces the effect of measurement error on the final constants. In more than 64% it will result in a better approximation, if the measurement errors are estimated correctly. The IOL constants can be calculated with higher precision using the weighted least squares method.
Purpose: To provide additional information on normal values of static pupil diameter measurements for binocular infrared pupillometry with PupilX, a commercial pupillometer, and assess the reproducibility of this device’s measurements. Methods: The pupil diameters from 91 study participants with normal eyes with an average age of 39.7 years (SD 16.4 years) were measured with PupilX under scotopic (0 lx), mesopic (1 lx), and photopic (16 lx) illumination. To assess the repeatability of the device, each measurement was repeated 5 times. Results: The mean pupil diameters were 6.5 mm (SD 1.3 mm), 5.5 mm (SD 1.2 mm), and 4.03 mm (SD 0.9 mm) under scotopic, mesopic, and photopic illumination. Left and right eyes showed no difference in mean pupil diameters. The mean unsigned anisocoria was 0.26 mm (SD 0.32 mm) under scotopic, 0.26 mm (SD 0.27 mm) under mesopic, and 0.19 mm (SD 0.19 mm) under photopic illumination. The decrease in pupil diameter with age was largest for scotopic (≈0.057 mm/y) and smallest for photopic illumination (≈0.025 mm/y). The repeatability of the pupillometer was better than 0.2 mm. Conclusions: This study provides reference values for age- and light-related pupil diameters measured with the PupilX digital pupillometer in normal subjects.
To compare corneal tomography measurements (elevation and pachymetry) as made by two corneal tomographers: Pentacam AXL and CASIA 2. The devices were used in a standard measuring mode. 77 normal eyes were measured five times with both devices. The data maps for anterior and posterior corneal elevation and pachymetry were exported and analyzed. Repeatability and average values were calculated for each valid data point on the exported data maps. We also calculated a corrected repeatability of the elevation data maps by removing rotation, tilt, and decentration through realignment of the elevation measurement of each eye prior to analyzing the variations in the measurement usingthe same method as for the repeatability. Pentacam AXL offered the better (corrected) repeatability for anterior corneal elevation measurements. CASIA 2 offered better repeatability for the pachymetry measurements. The tomographers could not be used interchangeably. The central corneal thickness was measured 9 μm ± 3 μm larger when measured with Pentacam AXL compared to CASIA 2.