The new economic geography (NEG) has become a mainstay of regional science in the last two decades, as signified by the awarding of Paul Krugman, the Nobel Prize. Yet, most American regional scientists and urban/regional economists do not use NEG in determining regional growth patterns. Instead, they rely on factors such as natural amenity migration, whose roots lie back to the work of Philip Graves in the mid 1970s. Conversely, two of the world's leading economic geographers – Allen Scott and Michael Storper – have strongly argued that job availability not household amenities have determined US regional dynamics. Given the disparity of views over the largest developed economy in the world, we hold a competition to determine which of these leading contenders accurately predict US interregional growth dynamics over the last 40–60 years. The runaway winner of the duel is natural amenity led growth with the crown going to Graves. Implications are drawn for both empirical research and EU economic integration. Resumen La nueva geografía económica (NEG, siglas en inglés) se ha convertido en un pilar de las ciencias regionales de las dos últimas décadas, ratificado por el Premio Nobel otorgado a Paul Krugman. A pesar de ello, la mayoría de científicos y economistas de ciencias urbanas/regionales no utilizan la NEG para determinar patrones de crecimiento regionales. En su lugar, se apoyan en factores tales como la migración natural por recreo, cuyas raíces se sustentan en el trabajo de Philip Graves de mediados de los 70. Por el contrario, dos de los líderes en geografía económica – Allen Scott y Michael Storper – han defendido enérgicamente que es la disponibilidad de empleos, y no la calidad de vida familiar, la que ha determinado las dinámicas regionales en los EE.UU. Dada la disparidad de opiniones acerca de la economía más desarrollada del mundo, organizamos un torneo para determinar cuáles de estos contendientes importantes son capaces de predecir la dinámica de crecimiento interregional en los EE.UU. durante los últimos 40–60 años. La victoria abrumadora del torneo es para el crecimiento motivado por recreo público natural, con los laureles para Graves. Formulamos implicaciones tanto para estudios empíricos como para la integración económica con la UE.
The sources of urban agglomeration and the development of the urban system have been studied extensively. Despite the pivotal role of the hinterlands in theories of the development of the urban system, little attention has been paid to the effect of urban agglomeration in a developed, mature economy on growth in the hinterlands. Therefore, this study examines how proximity to urban agglomeration affects contemporary population growth (PopGr) in hinterland U.S. counties. Proximity to urban agglomeration is measured in terms of both distances to higher tiered areas in the urban hierarchy and proximity to market potential (MP). Particular attention is paid to whether periodic changes and trends in underlying conditions (e.g. technology or transport costs) have altered PopGr patterns in the hinterlands and small urban centers. Over the period 1950–2000, we find strong negative growth effects of distances to higher tiered urban areas, with significant, but lesser effects of distance to MP. Further, the costs of distance, if anything, appear to be increasing over time, consistent with a number of recent theories stressing the effect of new technology on the spatial distribution of activity in a mature urban system.
Although the New Economic Geography (NEG) has been used extensively to formally explain the emergence of the American urban system, few studies investigate its success in explaining current population dynamics in a more established urban system. This study explores whether proximity to same-sized and higher-tiered urban centres affected the patterns of 1990-2006 US county population growth. Rather than casting NEG agglomeration shadows on nearby growth, larger urban centres generally appear to have positive growth effects for more proximate places of less than 250,000 people. However, there is some evidence the largest urban areas cast growth shadows on proximate medium-sized metropolitan areas and of spatial competition among small metropolitan areas. Copyright (c) 2009 the author(s). Journal compilation (c) 2009 RSAI.
Chen A. and Partridge M. D. When are cities engines of growth in China? Spread and backwash effects across the urban hierarchy, Regional Studies. China's remarkable growth has an urban bias, but it is unclear whether it has greatly disadvantaged particular regions. To assess this question, a Central Place Theory framework is employed to assess spread and backwash effects. It is found that New Economic Geography representations do not capture the heterogeneity across urban tiers. Market potential in China's mega-cities is inversely related to growth for smaller cities and rural communities, while medium-sized cities have positive spread effects. It is concluded that China's urban-centric process should be re-evaluated because it may not maximize aggregate growth, and growth in the mega-cities may reduce growth elsewhere.