On the semiarid Colorado Plateau, dryland farmers are challenged by degraded soils and unreliable precipitation. While cover crops have been shown to support soil fertility, control erosion, and enhance soil water capture, they also use limited soil water and, thus, may impact cash crop productivity in dryland systems. Most literature on cover crops comes from relatively humid climates, where yield penalties due to cover crops may be less pronounced. Two field trials were conducted in Southwestern Colorado to assess the short-term viability of cover crops in dryland systems in this region. The effect of cover crops on subsequent winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) yield ranged from a decrease of 78% to an increase of 13%, depending on the amount of cover crop biomass produced in the previous year. Cover crop biomass was inversely correlated with soil nitrate levels and soil water storage at wheat planting, which decreased by 0.39 mg kg−1 and 10 mm, respectively, per 1000 kg ha−1 of cover crop biomass produced. Less available soil water and immobilized N therefore appeared to contribute to wheat yield reductions. These impacts are particularly important for semiarid environments, where decomposition of residue is water-limited and soil water recharge depends on unpredictable precipitation patterns.
Voluntary markets for agricultural carbon credits are expanding, promoting climate-smart practices purported to increase soil carbon and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. To contribute effectively to climate mitigation, markets must deliver credits that meet international standards guaranteeing credits are additional, conservative, and equivalent to at least 1 ton of CO 2 . Yet protocols for quantifying credits make different assumptions, raising questions about whether protocols meet the ‘equivalency standard’. We test for equivalency using a common dataset of 4988 US Midwestern corn-soybean fields, representing a carbon market project, to estimate credit issuances for adoption of no-till plus cover cropping practices. We find issuances, across the three major protocols being used for US croplands, differing for this common project by up to ∼130 000 credits per year. Our ‘Protocol Intercomparison Project’ reveals how quantitative evaluations can identify assumptions generating marked differences in crediting, thereby guiding research that informs protocol revisions to build confidence in mitigation and demonstrating paths forward for protocol harmonization efforts.
Replacing bare fallow periods with cover crops in dryland agroecosystems can help reverse soil degradation and control erosion but may also result in cash crop yield penalties due to water limitations. Two field trials were conducted on the Colorado Plateau to quantify the impact of cover cropping on crop production, multiple ecosystem services, and economic trade‐offs in this semiarid region. No‐till and different cover crop planting windows (fall and spring) were explored as strategies to optimize ecosystem service provision and productivity trade‐offs. After three full cover crop cycles (6 years), fall‐planted cover crops improved soil structure and erosion control, offering critical soil health benefits for dryland producers. However, these benefits were associated with a decrease in available soil moisture at planting, causing lower and more variable wheat yields (average 48% yield penalty) and a US$176 ha−1 cycle−1 average decrease in net returns. Including the hypothetical sale of forage (based on 50% cover crop biomass removal) more than offset these costs in fall‐planted treatments; with both forage and wheat revenue, cover cropping increased net returns as compared to the fallow control by US$92 ha−1 cycle−1. Spring‐planted cover crops presented a lower productivity trade‐off (24% average wheat yield penalty) but did not provide clear ecosystem service benefits and did not produce enough biomass to offset costs of cover cropping. Our findings indicate that fall‐planted cover crops have the potential to reverse soil degradation and control erosion in dryland systems globally, but productivity trade‐offs and decreased economic returns must be compensated for by alternative revenue sources, conservation payments, or other incentives to ensure their feasibility.