Background: Infants who present with multiple unexplained fractures (MUF) are often diagnosed as victims of child abuse when parents deny wrongdoing and cannot provide a plausible alternative explanation. Herein we describe evidence of specific and commonly overlooked radiographic abnormalities and risk factors that suggest a medical explanation in such cases. Methods: We evaluated such infants in which we reviewed the radiographs for signs of poor bone mineralization. We reviewed medical, pregnancy and family histories. Results: Seventy-five of 78 cases showed poor bone mineralization with findings of healing rickets indicating susceptibility to fragility fractures that could result from a wide variety of causes other than child abuse. We found risk factors that could explain the poor bone mineralization: maternal and infant vitamin D deficiency (VDD), decreased fetal bone loading, prematurity and others. Most infants had more than one risk factor indicating that this bone disorder is a multifactorial disorder that we term metabolic bone disease of infancy (MBDI). Maternal and infant VDD were common. When tested, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D levels were often elevated, indicating metabolic bone disease. Conclusions: Child abuse is sometimes incorrectly diagnosed in infants with MUF. Appreciation of the radiographic signs of MBDI (healing rickets), risk factors for MBDI and appropriate laboratory testing will improve diagnostic accuracy in these cases.
1 June 2015 in American Journal of Forensic Medicine & Pathology
Infants with the triad (neurologic dysfunction, subdural hematoma [SDH], and retinal hemorrhage) are often diagnosed as victims of shaken baby syndrome. Medical conditions/predisposing factors to developing the triad are often dismissed: short falls, birth-related SDH that enlarges, macrocephaly, sinus/cortical vein thrombosis, and others. Six infants with the triad are described in which child abuse was diagnosed, but parents denied wrongdoing. All 6 had either macrocephaly or enlarging head circumference, which suggested medical explanations. Three infants incurred short falls, 1 had a difficult delivery in which there was likely a rebleed of a birth-related SDH, 1 had a spontaneous SDH associated with increased extra-axial fluid spaces, and 1 had a sinus thrombosis. Following legal proceedings, all 6 infants were returned to their parents, and there has been no child maltreatment in follow-up, suggesting child abuse never happened. The results indicate that alternative medical explanations for causing the triad should be considered and that macrocephaly or an enlarging head circumference raises the possibility of a medical explanation.
The objective of the present study was to review the histopathology in the original articles by authors Kleinman and Marks that described the specificity of the classical metaphyseal lesion for child abuse and to determine if there were any oversights in the authors' analysis. We reviewed the histopathology of the original studies that equated the classical metaphyseal lesion with child abuse. We compared this with the histopathology of metaphyseal fractures caused by known accidental, severe trauma in children and reviewed the histopathology of artifacts that can sometimes be produced in bone histology preparations. Acute classical metaphyseal lesions showed no hemorrhage, and the chronic classical metaphyseal showed islands of cartilage proliferation at the metaphyses and growth plate, findings consistent with rickets and other metabolic bone disorders. Some of the acute metaphyseal lesions were consistent with artifacts. We believe the original studies that equate the classical metaphyseal lesion with child abuse are flawed. The most compelling observation that challenges the histopathology of the classical metaphyseal lesion as being a fracture is the absence of hemorrhage in the acute classical metaphyseal lesion. We hypothesize that some of the classical metaphyseal lesions were artifacts or represent metabolic bone disorders that were not considered and that these two non-traumatic explanations may have been the basis of the abnormal bone findings.
The Utah Paradigm is the contemporary model of bone physiology that allows for an understanding of risk factors for bone fragility and can be used in understanding infants who present with multiple unexplained fractures in contested cases of child abuse. The Utah Paradigm was applied to the fetal period in over 500 cases of contested child abuse cases in infants with multiple unexplained fractures to determine if risk factors for bone fragility could be identified. Multiple risk factors for fetal bone fragility were identified: inadequate provision by the mother during pregnancy of essential bone nutrients (calcium, phosphate, vitamin D, and protein), prematurity, gestational diabetes, and fetal exposure to drugs that can affect bone strength. The most common risk factor was decreased fetal bone loading from decreased fetal movement. More than one risk factor was often identified in these cases, and the term Metabolic Bone Disease of Infancy is used to describe this multifactorial bone fragility disorder of young infants. Infants with Metabolic Bone Disease of Infancy have X-rays that show poor bone mineralization, and this condition can be misdiagnosed as child abuse. Metabolic Bone Disease of Infancy should be considered in infants with multiple unexplained fractures. This condition can be established by finding abnormal X-rays showing poor bone mineralization and risk factors for bone fragility. Fetal bone loading is the most critical determinant of fetal and young infant bone strength. Situations that cause decreased fetal movement can casue decreased fetal and young infant bone strength.