Scientific discussions in school classrooms are recent and scarce globally, with teaching characterized by unproductive patterns of interrogation-response-evaluation. Hence, knowing what can facilitate productive and argumentative discussions in science classrooms is critical. This study systematically reviews the literature and finds that such practices have dialogic/interactive purposes, assign roles, and specify participation structures, discourses, and teaching practices. The works reviewed also identify challenges in the curriculum, teacher education, and teacher beliefs in facilitating scientific discussions. Implications address pre-service and in-service teacher education, suggesting the inclusion of scientific argumentation, reinforcing scientific knowledge, and working on teacher beliefs about argumentation. Las discusiones científicas en aulas escolares a escala global son recientes y escasas, donde la enseñanza presenta patrones poco productivos de interrogación-respuesta-evaluación. Saber qué puede facilitar discusiones y argumentación en las aulas de ciencias es de alta relevancia. Este estudio revisa sistemáticamente la literatura y encuentra que dichas prácticas tienen propósitos dialógicos/interactivos, asignan papeles y especifican estructuras de participación, discursos y prácticas docentes. Los estudios también identifican desafíos para la facilitación de discusiones científicas en el currículum, la formación y las creencias docentes. Se sugieren, entre otras, implicaciones para la formación docente, inicial y continua, como la inclusión explícita de la argumentación científica y fortalecimiento diciplinar en ciencias, trabajando también sobre sus creencias.
3 June 2025 in Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning
Digital technology integration is a fundamental component of Mathematics Initial Teacher Education. Mathematics Teacher Educators (MTEs) are responsible for providing future teachers with equitable and high-quality technology experiences, given their pervasive role. Technology-related Beliefs of MTEs may influence the frequency and quality of these experiences, although we still lack enough understanding about this influence. To understand the relationship between levels of technology integration reported by Chilean MTEs and their technology-related beliefs, we distributed an online questionnaire to 450 MTEs, obtaining 85 complete responses. We analyzed the data utilizing structural equation modeling (SEM). Results suggest that beliefs explain 49% of MTE’s reported levels of technology integration, where “time-consuming” and “multiple representations” beliefs show the strongest link to MTEs´ levels of technology integration. These findings confirm that beliefs are a highly determining factor for MTEs’ technology integration, are coherent with the local incipient integration of technology, and signal digital technology uses rooted in the mathematical domain. These local findings can also contribute to the broader international context.