In modern distribution networks, addressing the issue of unintentional islanding—characterized as the inadvertent disconnection of distributed generation sources from the utility grid—continues to present a significant challenge. This phenomenon raises concerns that warrant further investigation due to its implications for system reliability and operational safety. The identification of islanding events is particularly complicated when local generation closely aligns with local demand, making detection difficult. The development of precise, rapid, and dependable methodologies for the detection of islanding in renewable and distributed generation systems requires compliance with rigorous standards. The current body of literature delineates an array of strategies for islanding detection, which can be systematically categorized into three primary approaches: ( i ) remote detection techniques, ( ii ) local detection methodologies, and ( iii ) machine learning-based classification-enabled intelligent classifiers. Recent advancements have garnered significant attention regarding the enhanced characteristics and benefits of intelligent methodologies in contrast to traditional approaches. Accurate and timely detection of islanding prevents hazardous back-feeding to the utility, protects inverter and downstream equipment from out-of-spec voltages and frequencies, preserves system stability during transition and reconnection, reduces the risk of large-scale protection miscoordination, and enables compliance with interconnection standards (e.g., IEEE 1547) that prescribe strict detection and ride-through requirements. However, achieving high detection accuracy introduces trade-offs: many high-performance techniques demand significant computational and communications resources, active methods may degrade power quality or increase nuisance trips, passive schemes suffer from large non-detection zones under near-balanced conditions, and machine-learning approaches require representative training data and careful feature engineering to avoid overfitting and poor generalization in realistic, noisy environments. This research provides a comprehensive overview of the transition from traditional techniques to intelligent islanding detection methodologies. Moreover, it elucidates the primary challenges, benefits, limitations, and prospective directions for research in intelligent detection schemes. Furthermore, this study provides a comprehensive and impartial analysis of intelligent classifier-based strategies for islanding detection that have been developed over the last decade. This research further examines various feature selection techniques and identifies the parameters most employed for efficient islanding detection. In conclusion, this comprehensive study presents a discussion of the findings obtained, along with strategic recommendations for future research initiatives within this field.