Six different particle size distribution (Gates–Gaudin–Schuhmann (GGS), Rosin–Rammler (RR), Lognormal, Normal, Gamma, and Swebrec) models were compared under different metallurgical coke grinding conditions (ball size and grinding time). Adjusted R2, Akaike information criterion (AIC), and the root mean of square error (RMSE) were employed as comparison criteria. Swebrec and RR presented superior comparison criteria with the higher goodness-of-fit and the lower AIC and RMSE, containing the minimum variance values among data. The worst model fitting was GGS, with the poorest comparison criteria and a wider results variation. The undulation Swebrec parameter was ball size and grinding time-dependent, considering greater b values (b > 3) at longer grinding times. The RR α parameter does not exhibit a defined tendency related to grinding conditions, while the k parameter presents smaller values at longer grinding times. Both models depend on metallurgical coke grinding conditions and are hence an indication of the grinding behaviour. Finally, oversize and ultrafine particles are found with ball sizes of 4.0 cm according to grinding time. The ball size of 2.54 cm shows slight changes in particle median diameter over time, while 3.0 cm ball size requires more grinding time to reduce metallurgical coke particles.
En este estudio se evaluó la eficiencia del sistema de molienda y clasificación en un circuito cerrado para una planta cementera. Se compararon los requerimientos energéticos determinados mediante el modelo de Bond con el consumo de energía calculado en planta utilizando el modelo de media móvil. Se identificaron las causas de las diferencias entre los cálculos teóricos y los valores reales considerando la clasificación de partículas mediante curvas de partición y el efecto Fish-Hook. Se encontró que los requerimientos energéticos de molienda en planta superan el modelo de Bond entre un 125.9-229.3% en términos de consumo de energía, debido a una eficiencia de clasificación bastante baja causada por el alto porcentaje de partículas finas en la corriente de rechazo. Lo anterior se evidenció en las curvas de clasificación a través del cortocircuito, el índice de claridad y el efecto Fish-Hook. Esto proporciona información para tomar medidas y mejorar la eficiencia del proceso. The efficiency of the grinding and classification system in a closed circuit for a cement plant was evaluated in this study. The energy requirements determined by the Fred Bond model were compared with the energy consumption calculated on-site using the moving average model. The causes of the discrepancies between theoretical calculations and actual values were identified by considering particle classification through partition curves and the Fish-Hook effect. It was found that the energy requirements for grinding in the plant exceed the Bond model by 125.9-229.3% in terms of energy consumption, due to a significantly low classification efficiency caused by a high percentage of fine particles in the grinding underflow stream. This was observed in the classification curves through the bypass, sharpness index, and Fish-Hook effect. This information provides insights for taking measures to improve process efficiency.
Specific rate of breakage (Sj) is an important parameter for grinding kinetics behavior due to it isreverserelated with the process energy consumption. Size grinding media, viscosity medium, and fine particle formation are some ofmodifiablevariableforto reduce the energy in the grinding process.Nowadays, there is no model that explains the relationship among Sj and parameters described above.Aclassification model based on linear discriminant analysisfor quartz wet grinding wasproposedto identify conditions with the high Sj.Three grinding kinetic behavior groups have been found through cluster analysis and two discriminant functions that explicate difference among groups. The first function was themost powerful differentiating dimension with 89.01% of prediction percentage,and the second onerepresented an additional significant dimension with 10.99%of prediction.