Collaborative research has become increasingly prominent since the mid-20th century. This article aspires to offer a fundamental ontology of a multidisciplinary research system. As a point of departure, we consider disciplinarity as a restricted language code as noted by Bernstein. The impetus for collaboration is found in a research problem’s transcendence of disciplinary bounds. This article makes several propositions that diverge from the consensus position regarding the formation and dynamics of a multidisciplinary system. Most notably that such a system adheres to the constituent elements of what could be regarded as a complex system, including an ensemble of elements, interactions between these elements, local disorder followed by the emergence of robust order and system memory. We propose that the internal communications and subsequent self-organization of such a system may be conceptualized as orientation signals, or ‘stigmergy’, analogous to those observed in swarms. System robustness, we argue, is a function of the individual researcher’s local autonomy and is, paradoxically, augmented by the weakness of communications across disciplinary bounds, along with the lack of central organization and the emphasis on research novelty. System memory, we argue, manifests itself in the ability of a researcher to change her/his route of inquiry, based on environmental feedback, whereby new information becomes incorporated into the adjusted research methodology. We propose that an emergent intelligence, at the level of the system, expresses itself in the unconcealment of the ‘form’ of the metaproblem. The theoretical model is empirically illustrated using, as an example, the contemporary field of renewable energy research, which is an area primed for collaborative research. It is anticipated that an improved understanding of multidisciplinary research systems provides insights into certain strengths particular to less integrated and self-organized forms of collaborative research along with a framework with which to improve the design and fostering of such systems.
1 April 2022 in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
Notwithstanding the rapidly growing body of literature on interdisciplinary research, several of the crucial dynamics in interdisciplinary research systems remain poorly understood and undertheorized. To this effect we seek to provide a ‘fundamental’ ontology of interdisciplinary research systems. We principally understand an interdisciplinary research system as a complex system consisting of researchers from different disciplines that have undergone a pseudomorphosis (i.e. a false formation) into a complicated system through the formation of a central organizing principle. The central organizing principle provides a stricter definition of the research problem and subsequently coalesces the intentionality of system agents through a unification of their disparate aims and methodologies. This pseudomorphosis is thereby associated with an exchange of individual freedom for organizational utility resulting in internal tensions which are, we argue, most prominently expressed in the interplay of epistemic incompatibilities between disciplines. We explore three frameworks for successfully navigating these incompatibilities: circumvention, which is based on avoidance of areas of disciplinary incompatibility; pragmatism, which is based on ignoring areas of compatibility; and disciplinary synthesis which involves a paradigm shift in researchers’ understanding of their disciplinary propositions resolving perceived incompatibilities. It is anticipated that this paper may be of benefit to researchers and organizers seeking to effectively structure interdisciplinary research projects, specifically in terms of framing the research problem and the modes of inquiry, and in structuring the interdisciplinary research team.
In some electricity markets, individual wind farms are obliged to provide point forecasts to the power purchaser or system operator. These decentralized forecasts are usually based on on-site meteorological forecasts and measurements, and thus optimized for local conditions. Simply adding decentralized forecasts may not capture some of the spatial and temporal correlations of wind power, thereby lowering the potential accuracy of the aggregated forecast. This paper proposes the explanatory variables that are used to train the kernel density estimator and conditional kernel density estimator models to derive day-ahead aggregated point and probabilistic wind power forecasts from decentralized point forecasts of geographically distributed wind farms. The proposed explanatory variables include (a) decentralized point forecasts clustered using the clustering large applications algorithm to reduce the high-dimensional matrices, (b) hour of day and month of year to account for diurnal and seasonal cycles, respectively, and (c) atmospheric states derived from self-organizing maps to represent large-scale synoptic circulation climatology for a study area. The proposed methodology is tested using the day-ahead point forecast data obtained from 29 wind farms in South Africa. The results from the proposed methodology show a significant improvement as compared to simply adding the decentralized point forecasts. The derived predictive densities are shown to be non-Gaussian and time-varying, as expected given the time-varying nature of wind uncertainty. The proposed methodology provides system operators with a method of not only producing more accurate aggregated forecasts from decentralized forecasts, but also improving operational decisions such as dynamic operating reserve allocation and stochastic unit commitment.
Wind energy is one of the fastest-growing renewable energy sources in the world. However, wind power is variable in all timescales. This variability is difficult to predict with perfect certainty, with potentially significant financial implications when rare extreme forecast errors occur. This paper focuses on three key aspects associated with the extreme errors of geographically distributed wind farms: suitable parametric distribution representation, effects of diurnality, seasonality and larger atmospheric circulations, and modeling multivariate distribution. The paper shows that some of the distributions commonly used for modeling forecast errors may be inappropriate in representing extreme errors. As the first contribution, this paper fits a Generalized Pareto distribution (GPD) from extreme value theory to achieve a better estimation of extreme errors. In the second contribution, this paper splits extreme errors by hour, month, and atmospheric states to investigate the statistical regularities of GPD parameters along diurnal and seasonal timescales and larger atmospheric circulations. In the third contribution, this paper uses copula functions to model multivariate extreme error distribution and investigates their effectiveness in providing a regional view of extreme errors. This paper tests the proposed methodology using the forecast error data obtained from 29 wind farms in South Africa. The results show that GPD outperforms commonly used distributions. Extreme errors have strong diurnal and seasonal components and vary significantly between SOM nodes. Copulas can be useful in providing a regional view of extreme errors. This paper improves the estimation of extreme errors, which is an important step toward better operating reserve allocation.