Oddball paradigms are frequently used to study auditory discrimination by comparing event-related potential (ERP) responses from a standard, high probability sound and to a deviant, low probability sound. Previous research has established that such paradigms, such as the mismatch response or mismatch negativity, are useful for examining auditory processes in young children and infants across various sleep and attention states. The extent to which oddball ERP responses may reflect subtle discrimination effects, such as speech discrimination, is largely unknown, especially in infants that have not yet acquired speech and language. Mismatch responses for three contrasts (non-speech, vowel, and consonant) were computed as a spectral-temporal probability function in 24 infants, and analyzed at the group level by a modified multidimensional scaling. Immediately following an onset gamma response (30–50 Hz), the emergence of a beta oscillation (12–30 Hz) was temporally coupled with a lower frequency theta oscillation (2–8 Hz). The spectral-temporal probability of this coupling effect relative to a subsequent theta modulation corresponds with discrimination difficulty for non-speech, vowel, and consonant contrast features. The theta modulation effect suggests that unexpected sounds are encoded as a probabilistic measure of surprise. These results support the notion that auditory discrimination is driven by the development of brain networks for predictive processing, and can be measured in infants during sleep. The results presented here have implications for the interpretation of discrimination as a probabilistic process, and may provide a basis for the development of single-subject and single-trial classification in a clinically useful context. An infant’s brain is processing information about the environment and performing computations, even during sleep. These computations reflect subtle differences in acoustic feature processing that are necessary for language-learning. Results from this study suggest that brain responses to deviant sounds in an oddball paradigm follow a cascade of oscillatory modulations. This cascade begins with a gamma response that later emerges as a beta synchronization, which is temporally coupled with a theta modulation, and followed by a second, subsequent theta modulation. The difference in frequency and timing of the theta modulations appears to reflect a measure of surprise. These insights into the neurophysiological mechanisms of auditory discrimination provide a basis for exploring the clinically utility of the MMR TF and other auditory oddball responses.
(1) Background: Research has demonstrated that early intervention for children who are hard-of-hearing (CHH) facilitates improved language development. Early speech perception abilities may impact CHH outcomes and guide future intervention. The objective of this study was to examine the use of a conditioned head turn (CHT) task as a measure of speech discrimination in CHH using a clinically feasible protocol. (2) Methods: Speech perception was assessed for a consonant and vowel contrast among 57 CHH and 70 children with normal hearing (CNH) aged 5–17 months using a CHT paradigm. (3) Results: Regardless of hearing status, 74% of CHH and 77% of CNH could discriminate /a-i/, and 55% of CHH and 56% of CNH could discriminate /ba-da/. Regression models revealed that both CHH and CNH performed better on /ba-da/ at 70 dBA compared to 50 dBA. Performance by hearing age showed no speech perception differences for CNH and children with mild hearing loss for either contrast. However, children with hearing losses ≥ 41 dB HL performed significantly poorer than CNH for /a-i/. (4) Conclusions: This study demonstrates the clinical feasibility of assessing early speech perception in infants with hearing loss and replicates previous findings of speech perception abilities among CHH and CNH.
Our objective was to examine the effects of hearing aid amplification on auditory detection and discrimination in infants who were hard of hearing (IHH) using a physiological measure of auditory perception. We recorded EEG from 41 sleeping IHH aged 1.04 to 5.62 months while presenting auditory stimuli in a mismatch response paradigm. Responses were recorded during two listening conditions for each participant: aided and unaided. Temporal envelopes of the mismatch response in the EEG alpha band (6–12 Hz) were extracted from the latent, time-frequency transformed data. Aided alpha band responses were greater than unaided responses for the deviant trials but were not different for the standard trials. Responses to the deviant trials were greater than responses to the standard trials for the aided conditions but were not different for the unaided conditions. These results suggest that the alpha band mismatch can be used to examine both detection and discrimination of speech and non-speech sounds in IHH. With further study, the alpha band mismatch could expand and refine our abilities to validate hearing aid fittings at younger ages than current clinical protocols allow.
Background: Perceptual attunement theory predicts that during the first year of life, infants’ neural responses to native speech sounds should strengthen while responses to nonnative contrasts diminish. However, few longitudinal studies have directly tested these predictions using within-subject designs. Methods: We recorded auditory event-related potentials (ERPs) from 84 typically developing infants at three time points (3, 6, and 12 months) using an oddball paradigm with native (/ba/-/da/) and nonnative (dental vs. retroflex /ʈa/) consonant contrasts. We examined developmental trajectories of the mismatch response (MMR) and obligatory components (P1, N1, P2) using linear mixed-effects models, with Session × Language interactions testing differential development for native versus nonnative contrasts. Center of mass analysis characterized spatial reorganization of ERP topography across development. Results: Contrary to perceptual attunement predictions, most ERP measures showed similar developmental trajectories for native and nonnative consonants. Of 14 interaction tests, only N1 latency for deviant waveforms showed a significant Session × Language interaction (p = 0.046, ηp² = 0.025). Significant main effects of Session on multiple measures confirmed ongoing auditory maturation. Center of mass analysis revealed systematic spatial reorganization: P1 showed posterior migration and leftward shifts (0.078 units displacement), while N1 and MMR exhibited anterior shifts, with nonnative consonants showing larger spatial reorganization for N1 (0.099 units vs. 0.058 units for native). Conclusions: Robust neural signatures of perceptual attunement for consonants may be more subtle, later-emerging, or stimulus-specific than commonly assumed. The dissociation between stable amplitude and migrating generators suggests that spatial location may be as important as response magnitude for characterizing auditory maturation during early infancy. Practically, equivalent neural responses to native and nonnative consonant contrasts should not be interpreted as evidence of atypical development; rather, indices of general auditory maturation may be more reliable markers of healthy development during the first year.
BackgroundPerceptual attunement theory predicts that during the first year of life, infants’ neural responses to native speech sounds strengthen while responses to nonnative contrasts diminish. Few longitudinal studies have tested this within-subjects with auditory event-related potentials (ERPs).MethodsWe recorded ERPs from 84 typically developing sleeping infants at 3, 6, and 12 months during an oddball paradigm with native (/ba/ vs. /da/) and nonnative (dental /ʈa/ vs. retroflex /t̪a/) consonant contrasts. Neural evidence was quantified with the Fmpi-WWE statistic, which uses each infant’s own background-noise spectrum to set an individualized significance threshold. Linear mixed-effects models tested Session × Language interactions in Fmpi-WWE log10F values, peak amplitudes and latencies, and scalp center of mass; cluster-based permutation tests examined the mismatch response (MMR) waveforms in two regions of interest (central and frontal).ResultsFmpi-WWE revealed a Session × Language interaction for Deviant responses in both ROIs (central F(2, 270) = 5.53, FDR p = 0.016; frontal F(2,277) = 5.31, FDR p = 0.016). Standard responses, the MMR contrast, peak measures, and centroid trajectories were all null after FDR correction. Cluster-permutation showed Native MMR narrowing frontally between 3 and 12 months and larger Nonnative than Native MMR centrally at 3 months. Session main effects on P1, N1, and P2 latencies confirmed maturation that did not differ by language.ConclusionsDifferential consonant attunement was detectable through an integrated per-recording measure of the deviant response, even when peak-based and MMR-contrast measures were null.