This study presents a psychometric instrument that measures academic capital in college students. Academic capital is a set of social processes that aid students in acquiring the knowledge and support necessary to access and navigate higher education. This study establishes the validity and reliability of the Academic Capital Scale. In addition to validating the six components of academic capital identified by St. John, Hu, and Fisher (2011), two additional components of academic capital were identified. Providing scholars and practitioners with a measure of academic capital allows institutions to critically examine and restructure their current support programs for high-risk college students.
This paper examines the developmental trajectories of students’ self-authored worldview commitments over four years of college and the reasons they offered for making associated developmental gains. Through a longitudinal, mixed methods approach, we unearthed four distinctive developmental trajectories of a nationally-representative cohort of 9,470 students enrolled across 122 institutions. We found that provocative encounters with worldview diversity — those that appropriately challenged students to examine their own religious commitments — served as catalysts for growth during college. The varied contexts of those provocative encounters, both inside and outside the college classroom, are highlighted in students’ own words. Implications for research are discussed.
To challenge “objective” conventions in quantitative methodology, higher education scholars have increasingly employed critical lenses (e.g., quantitative criticalism, QuantCrit). Yet, specific approaches remain opaque. We use a multimethod design to examine researchers’ use of critical approaches and explore how authors discussed embedding strategies to disrupt dominant quantitative thinking. We draw data from a systematic scoping review of critical quantitative higher education research between 2007 and 2021 (N = 34) and semi-structured interviews with 18 manuscript authors. Findings illuminate (in)consistencies across scholars’ incorporation of critical approaches, including within study motivations, theoretical framing, and methodological choices. Additionally, interview data reveal complex layers to authors’ decision-making processes, indicating that decisions about embracing critical quantitative approaches must be asset-based and intentional. Lastly, we discuss findings in the context of their guiding frameworks (e.g., quantitative criticalism, QuantCrit) and offer implications for employing and conducting research about critical quantitative research.
This five-year longitudinal study explores the potential influence of interdisciplinary science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) training on the development of innovation capacities among Ph.D. graduate students. Guided by Kegan’s (2009) constructive-developmental theory the research assesses how participation in an interdisciplinary program predicted the growth rate of student’s cognitive, social, and intrapersonal capabilities to innovate and develop contextually beneficial new ideas. The study uses a longitudinal design and hierarchical blocked regression using both a large control group with covariate-adjusted analyses and a smaller propensity score matched control group to evaluate these differential rates of innovation capacity development. Results demonstrate that five years of Ph.D. interdisciplinary training predicts an acceleration in the development of innovation capacities by well over one quarter of a standard deviation (β = .40-.41) – a very substantial increase. Stronger innovation capacities are observable in participating students’ creativity, proactivity, and teamwork across diverse fields. These findings highlight the potential of interdisciplinary STEM programs to meet modern scientific and industrial demands for innovative, adaptive researchers, while also underscoring challenges in scaling such programs within traditional academic structures. Implications for program design, student engagement, and the effectiveness of interdisciplinary approaches in higher education are discussed.