Rapid, specific, and sensitive identification of microbial pathogens is critical to infectious disease diagnosis and surveillance. Classical culture-based methods can be applied to a broad range of pathogens but have long turnaround times. Molecular methods, such as PCR, are time-effective but are not comprehensive and may not detect novel strains. Metagenomic shotgun next-generation sequencing (NGS) promises specific identification and characterization of any pathogen (viruses, bacteria, fungi, and protozoa) in a less biased way. Despite its great potential, NGS has yet to be widely adopted by clinical microbiology laboratories due in part to the absence of standardized workflows. Here, we describe a sample-to-answer workflow called PanGIA (Pan-Genomics for Infectious Agents) that includes simplified, standardized wet-lab procedures and data analysis with an easy-to-use bioinformatics tool. PanGIA is an end-to-end, multi-use workflow that can be used for pathogen detection and related applications, such as biosurveillance and biothreat detection. We performed a comprehensive survey and assessment of current, commercially available wet-lab technologies and open-source bioinformatics tools for each workflow component. The workflow includes total nucleic acid extraction from clinical human whole blood and environmental microbial forensic swabs as sample inputs, host nucleic acid depletion, dual DNA and RNA library preparation, shotgun sequencing on an Illumina MiSeq, and sequencing data analysis. The PanGIA workflow can be completed within 24 h and is currently compatible with bacteria and viruses. Here, we present data from the development and application of the clinical and environmental workflows, enabling the specific detection of pathogens associated with bloodstream infections and environmental biosurveillance, without the need for targeted assay development.

Quantitative real-time PCR and genomic sequencing have become mainstays for performing molecular detection of biological threat agents in the field. There are notional assessments of the benefits, disadvantages, and challenges that each of these technologies offers according to findings in the literature. However, direct comparison between these two technologies in the context of field-forward operations is lacking. Most market surveys, whether published in print form or provided online, are directed to product manufacturers who can address their respective specifications and operations. One method for comparing these technologies is surveying end-users who are best suited for discussing operational capabilities, as they have hands-on experience with state-of-the-art molecular detection platforms and protocols. These end-users include operators in military defense and first response, as well as various research scientists in the public sector such as government and service laboratories, private sector, and civil society such as academia and nonprofit organizations performing method development and executing these protocols in the field. Our objective was to initiate a survey specific to end-users and their feedback. We developed a questionnaire that asked respondents to (1) determine what technologies they currently use, (2) identify the settings where the technologies are used, whether lab-based or field-forward, and (3) rate the technologies according to a set list of criteria. Of particular interest are assessments of sensitivity, specificity, reproducibility, scalability, portability, and discovery power. This article summarizes the findings from the end-user perspective, highlighting technical and operational challenges.

Metagenomics is emerging as an important tool in biosurveillance, public health, and clinical applications. However, ease-of-use for execution and data analysis remains a barrier-of-entry to the adoption of metagenomics in applied health and forensics settings. In addition, these venues often have more stringent requirements for reporting, accuracy, and precision than the traditional ecological research role of the technology. Here, we present PanGIA ( Pan - G enomics for I nfectious A gents), a novel bioinformatics analysis platform for hosting, processing, analyzing, and reporting shotgun metagenomics data of complex samples suspected of containing one or more pathogens. PanGIA was developed to address gaps that often preclude clinicians, medical technicians, forensics personnel, or other non-expert end-users from the routine application of metagenomics for pathogen identification. Though primarily designed to detect pathogenic microorganisms within clinical and environmental metagenomics data, PanGIA also serves as an analytical framework for microbial community profiling and comparative metagenomics. To provide statistical confidence in PanGIA’s taxonomic assignments, the system provides two independent estimations of probability for species and strain level detection. First, PanGIA integrates coverage data with ‘uniqueness’ information mapped across each reference genome for a stand-alone determination of confidence for each query sequence at each taxonomy level. Second, if a negative-control sample is provided, PanGIA compares this sample with a corresponding experimental unknown sample and determines a measure of confidence associated with ‘detection above background’. An integrated graphical user interface allows interactive interrogation and enables users to summarize multiple sample results by confidence score, normalized read abundance, reference genome linear coverage, depth-of-coverage, RPKM, and other metrics to detect specific organisms-of-interest. Comparison testing of the PanGIA algorithm against a number of recent k-mer, read-mapping, and marker-gene based taxonomy classifiers across various real-world datasets with spiked targets shows superior mean positive predictive value, sensitivity, and specificity. PanGIA can process a five million paired-end read dataset in under 1 hour on commodity computational hardware. The source code and documentation are publicly available at https://github.com/LANL-Bioinformatics/PanGIA or https://github.com/mriglobal/PanGIA . The database for PanGIA can be downloaded from ftp://bioinformatics.mriglobal.org/ . The full GUI-based PanGIA analysis environment is available in a Docker container and can be installed from https://hub.docker.com/r/poeli/pangia/ .