Uncertainty quantification has proven to be an indispensable study for enhancing reliability and robustness of engineering systems in the early design phase. Single and multi-fidelity surrogate modelling methods have been used to replace the expensive high fidelity analyses which must be repeated many times for uncertainty quantification. However, since the number of analyses required to build an accurate surrogate model increases exponentially with the number of random input variables, most surrogate modelling methods suffer from the curse of dimensionality. As an alternative approach, the Low-Rank Approximation method can be applied to high-dimensional uncertainty quantification studies with a low computational cost, where the number of coefficients for building the surrogate model increases only linearly with the number of random input variables. In this study, the Low-Rank Approximation method is implemented for multi-fidelity applications with additive and multiplicative correction approaches to make the high-dimensional uncertainty quantification analysis more efficient and accurate. The developed uncertainty quantification methodology is tested on supersonic aircraft design problems and its predictions are compared with the results of single- and multi-fidelity Polynomial Chaos Expansion and Monte Carlo methods. For the same computational cost, the Low-Rank Approximation method outperformed both in surrogate modeling and uncertainty quantification cases for all the benchmarks and real-world engineering problems addressed in the present study.
10 November 2025 in Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering
As engineering systems increase in complexity and performance demands intensify, Multidisciplinary Design Optimization (MDO) methodologies are becoming essential for integrating models from multiple disciplines to optimize complex multi-physics systems. Within this context, major challenges remain in selecting appropriate disciplinary fidelity levels, and how to couple them effectively. Multifidelity methods offer a promising path forward by strategically combining information sources of varying fidelity - whether computational or experimental - to enable efficient and scalable design exploration and optimization. Despite the development of numerous multifidelity methods, their comparative performance remains difficult to assess due to the absence of standardized benchmark frameworks capable of evaluating performance across diverse optimization tasks. To address this gap, this paper introduces a comprehensive benchmarking framework that includes: (i) a suite of analytical benchmark optimization problems designed to stress-test and validate multifidelity methods; (ii) a set of assessment metrics for quantifying and comparing performance over measurable objectives; and (iii) the classification, evaluation, and comparison of several families of multifidelity optimization methods and frameworks using the proposed benchmarks to identify their respective strengths and weaknesses in real-world scenarios. The proposed benchmark problems are analytically defined functions carefully selected to capture mathematical challenges commonly encountered in real-world applications, including high dimensionality, multimodality, discontinuities, and noise. Their closed-form nature ensures computational efficiency, high reproducibility, and a clear separation of algorithmic behavior from numerical artifacts. The accompanying performance metrics support the systematic evaluation of multifidelity methods, measuring both optimization effectiveness and global approximation accuracy. By providing a rigorous, reproducible, and accessible benchmarking framework, this work aims to enable the broader community to understand, compare, and advance multifidelity optimization methods for complex problems in science and engineering.
The embedded weapon bay in military aircraft forms a cavity when opened to release stores. The complex unsteady flow dynamics and high levels of acoustic noise associated with these storage bays present significant design challenges for fighter aircraft. The primary objective of this study is to optimize the geometry of the cavity based on aerodynamic and aeroacoustic criteria using a constrained Bayesian approach. To represent the store bay, we use a generic M219 cavity geometry with a length-to-depth ratio of 5, along with experimental data from a wind tunnel test, to validate the methodology and model. During the optimization process, a computationally efficient aeroacoustic solution is generated using the Spalart–Allmaras turbulence model on a coarse mesh. In other words, solutions for each geometry can be obtained with approximately 80 $$\%$$ (1/6) shorter analysis run duration. The improved delayed detached Eddy simulation (IDDES) method is employed on a fine mesh to validate the optimized geometries with a higher-fidelity solution. Flow simulations are performed using the OpenFOAM HISA open-source solver. The acoustic signal, in other words the acoustic quantities (SPL, PSD and OASPL), is obtained by performing FFT transformation from probe-based, unsteady (time-dependent) pressure data obtained via the flow simulations. The results indicate that both low-fidelity and high-fidelity solutions accurately represent the aeroacoustic behavior of the cavity flow compared to the experimental data. Furthermore, the Bayesian optimization process achieved a reduction of approximately 5 $$\%$$ (7–10 dB) in OASPL and SPL values.