Great terrestrial surfaces in Europe are covered by grasslands. Fostered by climatic conditions, grasslands provide high above- and below-ground biomass and serve as a carbon sink. Grassland biomass is primarily used as cattle fodder. The influence of ruminant-based farming systems on yields, or soil properties in intensively managed grasslands is rarely investigated in long-term experiments. In this study, a matched-pairs field study compared former intensively managed grasslands: one part was fertilized with organic fertilizers (zone ZIII of the grassland fields), and the other with mineral fertilizers (zone ZII of the grassland fields). The abstinence from organic fertilization lasts between 10 and 30 years at the 23 sites of southern. Soil properties, such as SOC and TN or soil P, K, or pH, were determined using georeferenced soil sampling in 0 – 30 cm. Biomass production in grasslands was assessed using a satellite-based approach. The dataset included soil properties from soil analysis, site characteristics, management data, and plant parameters, and was statistically analyzed using a baseline model. ZIII of the grasslands with organic fertilization had significantly higher SOC contents, P values, and plant biomass than ZII without organic fertilization. Also, TN, K, and pH were higher in ZIII, but the differences were not statistically significant. The model output yielded back-transformed median SOC (and TN) contents of 4.83% (1.80%) in ZIII and 3.82% (1.63%) in ZII, both influenced by the zone effect and by the time without organic fertilization and temperature. The greatest differences between the zones were observed in soil P. In each study field, the stalleite-derived biomass potential of grassland was higher in ZIII compared to ZII. The study describes the effect of removing cattle from grasslands under practical condtitions. A sensitivity analysis dependent on estimated bulk densities also shows great differences in SOC stocks between the zones. Also, the grassland biomass in zones without organic fertilization was substantially lower. However, our results suggest that long-term organic fertilization with ruminant excrements may help maintain higher SOC concentrations in intensively managed grasslands. This should be considered when evaluating the climate performance of cattle farms. From a water-protection perspective, the ban on organic fertilization may also have unintended effects on SOC and soil organic matter that is important to many soil functions as aggregate stability, water inflitration, water retention, or biological activity.