The effects of the German Fertilizer Application Ordinance (GFO) on crop yield, nitrogen use efficiency and economical performance are highly controversial in science and practice in Germany. This study presents the results of a multi-year field experiment conducted at an experimental farm in southern Germany, in which the effects of different fertilizer systems on crop yield, protein concentration and nitrogen balance were analyzed.
Various fertilization systems have been developed to optimize nitrogen (N) application, yet their effectiveness remains a topic of debate in both science and practice. This study evaluates the effects of 28 N fertilization treatments on yield, quality, nitrogen use efficiency (NUE), N surplus, and economic optima in two winter barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) varieties—a multi-row and a two-row type—across a three-year field trial (2021–2023). Specifically, it compares the performance of fertilizer requirement calculations based on the German Fertilizer Application Ordinance (GFO), multispectral sensor-based fertilization systems, and fixed N input treatments. Under the trial conditions (highly productive fields without organic fertilization for decades), the GFO system consistently achieved high yields (>10 t ha−1) and NUE (up to 88%) for both barley varieties, often near economically optimal N rates and with minimal N surpluses. Sensor-based systems demonstrated promising potential for yield optimization and reducing N input; however, they did not result in significantly higher yields. Further research is needed to assess the performance of these fertilization systems under different conditions, such as sandy soils in regions with early-summer droughts or in systems involving organic fertilization.
Purpose: This study developed and validated an integrated framework to identify critical nitrate loss zones at sub-field scale in a drinking water protection area. The key question was whether satellite-based estimation of grain N uptake, combined with site-specific N balancing and soil–water–nitrate modeling, can reliably capture spatial patterns of nitrate leaching under practical farming conditions. Methods: A satellite-based algorithm was developed to estimate winter wheat N uptake using data from georeferenced plots in southern Germany. Multiple linear regression and Random Forest models were applied based on Sentinel-2 vegetation indices, as well as soil, topographic, and climatic variables. Results and Discussion: The Random Forest model performed slightly better (R 2 = 0.74, RMSE = 14.8 kg ha⁻ 1 , MAE = 11.2 kg ha⁻ 1 ) than the linear regression model (R 2 = 0.70, RMSE = 16.0 kg ha⁻ 1 , MAE = 12.5 kg ha⁻ 1 ). Predicted N uptake was combined with field-specific fertilization data to calculate site-specific N balances, which were integrated into a soil–water–nitrate leaching model. Low-yield zones showed lower N uptake but higher N surplus, modeled nitrate leaching, and measured nitrate–N stocks in deeper soil layers compared to high-yield zones. During validation (Field A), low-yield zones showed N surpluses of 98 kg ha⁻ 1 and modeled nitrate concentrations of 120 mg L⁻ 1 in seepage water, compared to 33 kg ha⁻ 1 and 49 mg L⁻ 1 in high-yield zones. Modeled nitrate concentrations correlated with measured nitrate–N stocks (R 2 = 0.68). The approach shows strong potential for identifying nitrate-prone areas and enabling targeted measures for drinking water protection.