Nutrient recovery from biomass streams generates novel recycling-derived fertilizers (RDFs). The effect of RDFs depends on their nutrient content and variability, which can aid or hinder their use by end-users. Detailed characterization of RDFs can help in evaluating product properties, whereas blending RDFs can optimize their nutrient ratios and reduce nutrient variability. This study assesses ammonium nitrate (AN) from stripping-scrubbing, ammonium water (AW) and concentrate (CaE) from evaporation, and two tailor-made blends (AN + CaE and AW + CaE), for their potential as nitrogen (N) fertilizers in the pot cultivation of lettuce. Parallelly, a soil incubation experiment was conducted to investigate the N release dynamics of the tested RDFs. The RDFs were compared against the commercial calcium ammonium nitrate (CAN) and an unfertilized control. AN and AW fertilization resulted in a similar crop yield and N uptake to the CAN treatment. CaE and blends exhibited poor yield and N uptake, possibly due to the sodium toxicity detected. AN and AW displayed N fertilizer replacement values above 100%, whereas CaE and blends exhibited poor results in the current experiments. The soil incubation experiment showed a positive soil priming effect in AN and AW treatment, as their N release was over 100%. Further research under uncontrolled field conditions utilizing AN and AW for diverse crop types can validate their N replacement potential.

Recently, the EU approved RENURE-criteria materials to be used as substitutes for synthetic N fertilisers. Several studies have been performed on the agronomic efficacy and potential environmental impacts of different bio-based fertilisers (BBFs) from biomass recovery, including the RENURE-criteria materials. But information is lacking about their effectiveness under abiotic stress conditions like salinity and drought. The predictions for climate change-induced increased drought and soil salinisation for the European soils have also increased, making it inevitable to understand BBF performance in these impending situations. Two RENURE-criteria top-priority materials (ammonium nitrate (AN) and ammonium sulphate (AS) and another commercially used BBF—an evaporator concentrate (CaE)) were evaluated in a pot trial growing spinach under salinity and drought stress with a reference ‘no stress’ condition to examine crop growth, nutrient uptake, and nitrogen fertiliser replacement value (NFRV). Agronomically, BBFs performed at par with the synthetic fertiliser (SF) under unstressed and salt-stressed conditions, whereas, under drought stress, BBFs outperformed the SF treatment. AS exhibited the highest yield and nutrient uptake, displaying an NFRV of 3.1 and 1.8 under no-stress and salt-stress conditions, respectively. Salt stress did not negatively impact the crops grown in this trial, potentially due to the higher potassium content in the system, which alleviated the possible negative impacts of high sodium. This study delves into the agronomic response, without evaluating crop physiological changes, and, hence, should be taken as a preliminary step into further investigation of observed elemental interactions (that could be potentially driving stress mitigation) while also examining the crop physiology during the duration of stress.