This paper discusses the importance of introducing domestic natural rubber production and presents the rediscovery of a rubber-producing species, Scorzonera tau-saghyz or “mountain gum”, originally discovered in 1929 on the Karatau mountains in Kazakhstan. This plant could potentially also be cultivated in the U.S. In this exploratory work, roots (2–5 years old) were harvested on June 16, 2021 from wild strands in the Karatau mountains, Kumantas ridge, and Saraba, Kazakhstan, and processed at the Ohio State University. The rubber extraction method was based on an indigenous method in Kazakhstan to make natural chewing gum. Water extraction followed by purification yielded 16.2 wt% rubber from the dry roots, in comparison with 4–8 wt% from most rubber dandelion (Taraxacum kok-saghyz) plants, also a potential domestic rubber producing plant. High-resolution size exclusion chromatography was used to analyze rubber samples. The molecular weights and gel and oligomer contents were very similar to the rubber from Hevea brasiliensis, the current commercial source of natural rubber. More detailed investigations of this very interesting rubber-producing plant are in progress.