Residual alveolar ridge resorption often occurs after tooth extraction, which causes issues requiring further prothesis rehabilitation. A treatment concept referred to as all-on-four, involving fixed dentures supported with four implants, was recently developed. The current study aimed to determine the effect of changing bone atrophy and implant length in all-on-four treatments on stress and strain in the surrounding bone of the implant. A three-dimensional finite element method was used in this research. The stress analysis was conducted with von Mises stress values. Two types of synthetic jawbone models with mild and moderate atrophy were used. Furthermore, two different implant lengths with a similar implant design and diameter were selected, and they were classified into eight models. Then, the bone model was assessed via a computed tomography (CT) scan and was transformed into a virtual model in Geomagic and SolidWorks with implant rebuilding. After modifying bone atrophy, the von Mises stresses in the surrounding bone of the implant were as follows: mild type 2 < mild type 3 < moderate type 3 < moderate type 4. The bone quantity change rate increased more than when bone conditions were limited. Compared with changes in implant lengths, the stresses in the peri-implant surrounding bone were generally higher in the 9 mm implant length group than in the 11.5 mm group. However, the results did not significantly differ. In conclusion, the von Mises stress and strain increased in the models with moderate atrophy and low-density trabecular bone. Hence, bone atrophy and its presurgical diagnosis in long-term implant prognosis are crucial.