China has significantly reduced the energy consumption for per unit of GDP by using both command-and-controls or market-based strategies. This paper examines empirically the relative effectiveness and efficiency of command-and-control strategy (energy reduction target) vs. market-based strategy (electricity price). We find that (1) electricity price was similarly effective in reducing electricity intensity across firms, but government targets were more effective for firms that were more technologically outdated and energy intensive; and (2) government targets led to expenditures that were not useful in reducing energy intensity, suggesting inefficiency associated with targets. Despite the Chinese governments’ capacities and resources in directing and influencing enterprises, market-based approaches might still be more effective and efficient than command-and-control ones to reduce energy intensity.
30 November 2020 in International Journal on Artificial Intelligence Tools
Medical savings accounts (MSAs), personal medical accounts that are restricted for health-care consumption only, have been widely adopted to cushion individuals against the financial risk due to illness and to address the potential moral hazard problem in the health insurance system. This paper studies the effects of MSAs on health-care expenditures and suggests that there may be some inherent tension between the two purposes of MSAs: account holders are likely to discount MSA funds because of their restricted use, which renders MSAs to be less effective in controlling health-care costs. We exploit a quasi-natural experiment in China that exogenously reduced MSA funds for enrollees in certain age cohorts. We find that this reduction led to a large and statistically significant decrease in health-care expenditures that is unlikely due to an income effect. The effect was driven by enrollees who were likely to exhaust MSA funds and enter the deductible phase in which they paid out-of-pocket.