There has recently been considerable discussion of those features of IFRS that are likely to help improve financial reporting in the European Union. However, certain issues may also have a negative impact on the quality of information. This paper focuses on the effect of IFRS on earnings management. Its main purpose is to examine whether the adoption of IFRS in the European Union has increased or decreased the scope for discretionary accounting practices by comparing discretionary accruals in the periods preceding and immediately after the regulatory change. Another objective is to determine which firms' features and country factors may explain the accounting discretion observed before and after IFRS. We consider a sample of non-financial firms listed on 11 EU stock markets. The results obtained show that earnings management has intensified since the adoption of IFRS in Europe, as discretionary accruals have increased in the period following implementation. The variables explaining accounting discretion are the same before and after IFRS (business size, leverage, investor protection and legal enforcement). These results suggest that variations in earnings management might be due to some room for manipulation under international standards when compared with local standards.
The study assesses and compares the value relevance (VR) of accounting numbers in entities that experienced high discretionary accruals intensity and so possible earnings management (EM) behaviours, testing whether and in what extent the quality of enforcement and governance mechanisms act as moderating factors on the relation EM-VR. Based on a sample of 2 667 European non-financial entities, the results show that while the VR of earnings is low in entities that experienced high discretionary accruals intensity, book value increases its VR. The study also shows that the quality of enforcement mechanisms and the ownership diffusion (that proxies the quality of corporate governance) are effectively able to obstruct the loss of VR of earnings. The value added of the paper consists in showing that both the quality of enforcement and the ownership diffusion contrast only in part and in different manner the loss of VR of earnings, due to the presence of EM behaviours, acting only in part as moderating factors.
1 August 2011 in Revista de Contabilidad - Spanish Accounting Review
ResumenBasándonos en los grupos cotizados en el mercado español, el presente trabajo aporta evidencia empírica sobre el impacto de la crisis en las prácticas de earnings management. Utilizamos los ajustes por devengo discrecionales como medida de manipulación. Los resultados obtenidos constatan que la calidad de la información financiera se ve afectada en periodos de crisis, ya que ponen de manifiesto que la manipulación al alza del resultado vía ajustes por devengo discrecionales se ha visto incrementada ante las dificultades económicas y financieras. Esto es debido no a la crisis en sí misma, sino a que la crisis ha reforzado la importancia de algunos incentivos para manipular, como es el endeudamiento.AbstractThe study analyses the impact of the crisis on the earnings management by listed companies on Spanish stock market. We use discretionary accruals as a measure of earnings management. The results show that earnings-increasing discretionary accruals have increased during the crisis, confirming that crisis periods affect to financial reporting quality. This is not due to crisis as such, but the crisis has strengthened some incentives to manage earnings, such us the indebtedness
29 May 2009 in Journal of Applied Accounting Research
Purpose – The purpose of the this paper is to discover the quantitative impact of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) on financial reporting of European countries and evaluate if this impact is connected with the traditional accounting system in which each country is classified, either the Anglo-Saxon or the continental-European accounting system. Design/methodology/approach – First, the authors quantify the IFRS impact on each country and make a comparative analysis of that impact among countries. Then, the authors apply a cluster analysis in order to group European countries on the basis of the different effects of IFRS application. Findings – The results obtained show that the first application of IFRS has had different effects on the financial reporting among countries. The cluster analysis identifies four groups which show that the impact of IFRS on financial statements of European firms is not related to traditional accounting systems. Originality/value – The main contribution of the paper is that it studies the impact of mandatory IFRS application for several European countries and shows a comparative analysis, grouping the countries on the basis of that impact. Previous literature mainly gathers research related to specific countries, individually considered, or to different IFRS effects that do not reflect quantitative impacts.