By means of comparing the VHCF response of heat-treated alloy steel, several factors governing the transition from surface (type I) to internal (type II) VHCF failure, and, in the case of internal inclusion and non-inclusion type II VHCF failure, are discussed: differences in strength, differences in grain size and strength gradients. Therefore, the steel grades (i) 50CrMo4 (0.5 wt%C–1.0 wt%Cr–0.2 wt%Mo) in two different tempering conditions (37HRC and 57HRC) but of the same prior austenite grain size, and (ii) 16MnCrV7 7 (0.16 wt%C–1.25 wt%Mn–1.7 wt%Cr) in the bainitic and martensitic thermomechanical treatment state, were studied. It is concluded that steels of moderate strength (37HRC) exhibit a real endurance limit (109 cycles), while the fatigue strength of high strength (43–57HRC) or coarse-grained steels (37HRC) decreases with increasing number of load cycles.
In this study, we investigate the influence of control type and strain rate on the lifetime of specimens manufactured from 50CrMo4. This influence is described by a strain rate dependent method that uses cyclic stress strain curves to correct displacement-controlled cyclic test results. The objective of this correction is to eliminate the stress related differences between displacement-controlled cyclic test results and force-controlled cyclic test results. The method is applied to the results of ultrasonic fatigue tests of six different combinations of heat treatment, specimen geometry (notch factor) and atmosphere. In a statistical analysis, the corrected results show an improved agreement with test results obtained on conventional fatigue testing equipment with similar specimens: the standard deviation in combined data sets is significantly reduced (p = 4.1%). We discuss the literature on intrinsic and extrinsic strain rate effects in carbon steels.