Society greatly expects the widespread deployment of automated vehicles (AVs). However, the absence of a driver role results in unresolved communication issues between pedestrians and AVs. Research has shown the crucial role of implicit communication signals in this context. Nonetheless, it remains unclear how pedestrians subjectively estimate vehicle behaviour and whether they incorporate these estimations as part of their crossing decisions. For the first time, this study explores the impact of implicit communication signals on pedestrians' subjective estimations of approaching vehicle behaviour across a wide range of experimental traffic scenarios and on their crossing decisions in the same scenarios through a comprehensive analysis. Two simulator tasks, namely a natural road crossing task and a vehicle behaviour estimation task, were designed with controlled time to collision, vehicle speed, and deceleration behaviour. A novel finding is that the correlation between crossing decisions and vehicle behaviour estimations depends on the traffic scenario. Pedestrians' recognition of different deceleration behaviour aligned with their crossing decisions, supporting the notion that they actively estimate vehicle behaviour as part of their decision-making process. However, if the traffic gap was long enough, the effects of vehicle speed were the opposite between crossing decisions and estimations, suggesting that vehicle behaviour estimation may not directly impact crossing decisions when the time gap to the vehicle is large. We also found that pedestrians crossed the street earlier and estimated yielding behaviour more accurately in early-onset braking scenarios than in late-onset braking scenarios. Interestingly, vehicle speed significantly affected pedestrians' estimations, with pedestrians tending to perceive low vehicle speed as yielding behaviour regardless of whether the vehicle yielded. Finally, we demonstrated that visual cue τ̇ is a practical indicator for controlling the vehicle deceleration evidence in the experiment. In conclusion, these findings reveal in detail the role of deceleration parameters as implicit communication signals between pedestrians and AVs, with implications for road crossing safety and the development of AVs.
Distractions have been recognised as one important factor associated with pedestrian injuries, as the increasing use of cell phones and personal devices. However, the situation is less clear regarding the differences in the effects of visual-manual and auditory-cognitive distractions. Here, we investigated distracted pedestrians in a one-lane road with continuous traffic using an immersive CAVE-based simulator. Sixty participants were recruited to complete a crossing task and perform one of two distractions, a visual-manual task and an auditory-cognitive task. Moreover, normal and time pressure crossing conditions were included as a baseline and comparison. For the first time, this study directly compared the impacts of visual-manual, auditory-cognitive distractions, and time pressure on pedestrian crossing behaviour and safety in a controlled environment. The results indicated that although pedestrian safety was compromised under both types of distraction, the effects of the applied distractions were different. When engaged in the visual-manual distraction, participants crossed the road slowly, but there was no significant difference in gap acceptance or initiation time compared to baseline. In contrast, participants walked slowly, crossed earlier, and accepted smaller gaps when performing the auditory-cognitive distraction. This has interesting parallels to existing findings on how these two types of distractions affect driver performance. Moreover, the effects of the visual-manual distraction were found to be dynamic, as these effects were affected by the gap size. Finally, compared to baseline, time pressure resulted in participants accepting smaller time gaps with shorter initiation times and crossing durations, leading to an increase in unsafe decisions and a decrease in near-collisions. These results provide new evidence that two types of distraction and time pressure impair pedestrian safety, but in different ways. Our findings may provide insights for further studies involving pedestrians with different distraction components.
7 November 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems
Increasing attention has been drawn to computational pedestrian behavior models aimed at understanding the interaction mechanisms between pedestrians and vehicles. Nevertheless, existing research lacks exploration of the underlying behavioral mechanisms of pedestrian crossing decisions, which leads to unrealistic modeling results. In particular, when dealing with continuous traffic flow scenarios, the concept of waiting time is frequently used to account for all intricate traffic flow effects. Moreover, very few studies considered the time-dynamic nature of crossing decisions. To address these research limitations, this study deconstructs pedestrian crossing decisions at uncontrolled intersections with continuous traffic flow through a cognitive process and proposes an anthropomorphic crossing decision model. Specifically, we propose a novel visual collision cue-based crossing decision-initiation model to characterize time-dynamic crossing decisions. In light of the risk-aversion theory, a traffic gap comparison strategy is put forward to explain and model pedestrian waiting behavior in traffic flow. Two datasets collected from a CAVE-based immersive pedestrian simulator are applied to calibrate and validate the model. The proposed model accurately predicts pedestrian crossing decisions across all traffic scenarios. The modeling performance is significantly enhanced by considering the proposed traffic gap comparison strategy. Moreover, the model accurately captures the timing of crossing decisions. This work concisely demonstrates how pedestrians dynamically adapt their crossings in continuous traffic based on visual collision cues, potentially offering insights into modeling pedestrian-vehicle interactions or serving as a tool to realize anthropomorphic pedestrian crossing decisions in simulators.
As autonomous driving technology advances, automated vehicles (AVs) will increasingly share road space with pedestrians, creating significant challenges for AV systems. Effective interaction between AVs and pedestrians is one of the key hurdles. Pedestrian simulation tools offer the potential to expedite the evaluation and refinement of these interactive capabilities. However, existing research lacks efforts to model pedestrian behavior in vehicle-yielding scenarios, resulting in distorted modeling results. This paper proposes a perceptually plausible road-crossing decision model that creates temporal-dynamic crossing decisions across a range of vehicle-yielding scenarios. Specifically, a proposed hybrid perception strategy explains how pedestrians may apply psychophysical cues to make crossing decisions. Discrete choice models based on the hybrid perception strategy combined with a crossing initiation model reproduce the details of crossing decisions: the decision and its timing. An empirical dataset collected in a pedestrian simulator is applied to validate the model. Additionally, the latest crossing decision models, i.e., the evidence accumulation model and the artificial neural networks approach, are employed as comparisons. The results show that the proposed model accurately reproduces crossing decision patterns affected by diverse vehicle kinematics in vehicle-yielding scenarios in a perceptually plausible manner. Our results strengthen the notion that there is a perceptual threshold for pedestrians to control their decision-making strategy. The proposed theory and approach bring insights into the computational pedestrian road-crossing behavior and have practical implications in traffic simulation and AV development.