The purpose of this study was to examine executive functions in team sport athletes with and without a history of concussion. Executive functions comprise many cognitive processes including, working memory, attention and multi-tasking. Past research has shown that concussions cause difficulties in vestibular-visual and vestibular-auditory dual-tasking, however, visual-auditory tasks have been examined rarely. Twenty-nine intercollegiate varsity ice hockey athletes (age = 19.13, SD = 1.56; 15 females) performed an experimental dual-task paradigm that required simultaneously processing visual and auditory information. A brief interview, event description and self-report questionnaires were used to assign participants to each group (concussion, no-concussion). Eighteen athletes had a history of concussion and 11 had no concussion history. The two tests involved visuospatial working memory (i.e., Corsi block test) and auditory tone discrimination. Participants completed both tasks individually, then simultaneously. Two outcome variables were measured, Corsi block memory span and auditory tone discrimination accuracy. No differences were shown when each task was performed alone; however, athletes with a history of concussion had a significantly worse performance on the tone discrimination task in the dual-task condition. In conclusion, long-term deficits in executive functions were associated with a prior history of concussion when cognitive resources were stressed. Evaluations of executive functions and divided attention appear to be helpful in discriminating participants with and without a history concussion.
Individuals with a concussion history tend to perform worse on dual-tasks compared controls but the underlying neural mechanisms contributing to these deficits are not understood. This study used event-related potentials (ERPs) to investigate sensory gating and cognitive processing in athletes with and without a history of concussion while they performed a challenging dual-task. We recorded sensory (P50, N100) and cognitive (P300) ERPs in 30 athletes (18 no previous concussion; 12 history of concussion) while they simultaneously performed an auditory oddball task and a working memory task that progressively increased in difficulty. The concussion group had reduced auditory performance as workload increased compared to the no-concussion group. Sensory gating and cognitive processing were reduced in the concussion group indicating problems with filtering relevant from irrelevant information and appropriately allocating resources. Sensory gating (N100) was positively correlated with cognitive processing (P300) at the hardest workload in the no-concussion group but negatively correlated in the concussion group. Concussions result in long-term problems in behavioral performance, which may be due to poorer sensory gating that impacts cognitive processing. Problems effectively gating sensory information may influence the availability or allocation of attention at the cognitive stage in those with a concussion.
Visuospatial working memory is often assessed using the Corsi block-tapping task where set size is used to estimate capacity. It is well established that characteristics of the Corsi task path configuration such as length, crossings, and angles influence recall accuracy suggesting that more complex path configurations increase the load on working memory. However, the interaction between set size and path configuration is not well understood. Here we used a secondary auditory task to probe if set size and path configuration impose a similar type of load on the system. Nineteen participants (age = 25.3 ± 3.9 years) performed a computerized version of the Corsi test either alone (single) or simultaneously with an auditory tone discrimination task (dual). The eCorsi task involved a set of simple (no crosses, shorter lengths, larger angles) or complex (>2 crosses, longer lengths, smaller angles) paths at set sizes of five to eight blocks. Results showed significantly lower recall accuracy for the complex compared to the simple paths (63.32% vs. 86.38%, p < 0.001) at all set sizes, regardless of task condition (single, dual). Auditory performance (accuracy and response time) was significantly lower in the dual compared to single task (85.34% vs. 99.67%, p < 0.001), but performance was not affected by the complexity of the eCorsi path configuration. These findings suggest that set size and path complexity impose a different type of load on the working memory system and may rely on different resources.
Cognitive functions are often impacted by concussions and neurocognitive tests are used to assess the recovery process. However, these tests lack sensitivity in tracking the recovery process, which may depend on genetic polymorphisms. Brain derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is an important nerve growth factor linked with development and neural plasticity. The Val66Met (rs6265) polymorphism has been associated with reduced activity-dependent BDNF secretion, indicating reduced plasticity and greater stability of cortical networks. While most studies found that Met carriers have poorer scores on memory tests, not all studies are in agreement. The purpose of our study was to examine the consequences of Val/Met genotype on the performance of a cognitively demanding dual task, which involved visual spatial working memory (Corsi block test) and an auditory tone discrimination task. Participants were varsity athletes (n=33). All athletes were cleared to play at the time of testing; however, 19 players had a history of at least one concussion. BDNF genotyping was performed using saliva samples, which showed that 18% of athletes were Met allele carriers. The main outcome for the cognitive task was dual task cost (i.e., the percent reduction in performance on the auditory task while concurrently performing the visual task). Since subjects were asked to focus on the Corsi block test, performance on this task was similar during single and dual conditions. Regression analysis revealed that BDNF genotype accounted for 13% of variance in the auditory cost, while the presence of a concussion explained 11% of variance. Met carriers were significantly more accurate in the auditory task in the dual condition in comparison to the Val/Val athletes. These results are in agreement with a recent study which showed that subjects with the Met allele had significantly better performance on a visuomotor adaptation task.11Barton et al (2014). J Vis, 14(9): 4; doi:10.1167/14.9.4 Meeting abstract presented at VSS 2015