A Chinese classic novel The Journey to the West (Chinese: 西游记, pinyin: Xi You Ji) has been yielding large volumes of English renditions across genres and media in the past 120 years starting in 1895. This body of renderings gives considerable material for research on how particularly translations have been handled. To give an overview of this research, this article proposes a bibliometric analysis to sketch a map of the translation studies conducted so far on The Journey to the West. A series of queries are made: which translators are most researched; which translations are most often compared with each other; which research questions are most addressed or ignored; which theories are most applied to resolve these questions. As Rovira-Esteva et al. state, “we need maps to know where we are so as to be helped instead of unconsciously being steered by them” (p. 160). The multiple and complementary perspectives we provide in this article are constructive to identify problems and lacunas and point out future directions. The present analytical framework has been applied to English translations of a Chinese classic, but we believe it can be successfully extrapolated to other similar cases.
With the aim of filling the gap in the research on real readers’ perception in stylistic research, this study adopts a mixed-method approach integrating quantitative and qualitative data analysis in order to systematically compare reader reviews on Anthony Yu’s two English translations of The Journey to the West. The comparison is divided into two steps. The first step is to winnow out representative reader comments from Amazon Books with the aid of the corpus tool ProtAnt. The other is to graphically represent the readers’ perception by annotating the reviews according to the hierarchy of the contained codes, categories, and themes using qualitative data analyzer RQDA. In addition, this research cross-references reader’s perception on the two translations with the translator’s voice, i.e., how the translator reflects on his self-retranslation.
4 January 2018 in Australian Journal of Linguistics
While the tension between stylistic prescriptions and authorial practice in academic writing has attracted much attention in recent years, one common feature which is less fully explored is whether to attend demonstrative this (as in ‘this uncertainty is because … ’) or to leave this unattended (as in ‘this is because … ’). Based on a corpus of 160 research articles from eight disciplines, this study explores the authorial practice of this rhetorical choice, revealing how academic writers manage it to organize their arguments and persuade peers of their claims. In contrast to the style guides which recommend avoidance of unattended this, our data show that 35% of demonstrative this were unattended for rhetorical purposes in different knowledge fields. We also discuss differences in how writers in different disciplines favour diverse attending nouns to encapsulate the particular aspect of information their readers are likely to find most familiar, plausible and persuasive. We conclude that (un)attended this is a key feature in academic author’s interactional resources, allowing them to build interaction with readers and claim credit for their ideas.
As one of the four great classical novels of Chinese literature, The Journey to the West narrates a legendary Buddhist pilgrimage. Until now, the religious conversion in the novel remains much less explored by academia. We propose an innovative approach to addressing this shortfall by conducting a corpus-based investigation into the characterization of the protagonist “Great Sage.” We use the corpus tools BFSU PowerConc 1.0 and LancsBox v.2.0.1 to calculate and visualize the collocation networks of Great Sage: for one thing, to contextualize the complex interactions between him and the external environment; for another, to define and compare different phases of the character’s evolution. The collocational networks are derived by means of a quantitative approach, i.e. a mutual information (MI) score with collocation cutoff values. This lays an objective foundation for a subsequent qualitative interpretation of how the protagonist’s identity is forged in his conversion. Further, some associated literary and theological scholarships are woven into our text-based analysis.
This paper aims to chart the diachronic progression of the English retranslations of Xi You Ji (The Journey to the West) and the intercultural trajectories of this ancient Chinese fictional canon. Empirically informed by WorldCat, the world’s largest library catalogue, this study shows that retranslation progressively enables a national literature from a third world to exert a global influence. The century-long retranslation of The Journey to the West has undergone four cohesive phases from religious hybridism, secularisation, religious restoration to multimedia adaptation, registering an enormous proliferation since the twenty-first century. In addition, inter-semiotic translation, in the form of children’s books, films, and television products, contributes strikingly to the literary impact of the source text. Reformulation and reinterpretation are also important themes in the process of retranslation, and they can be regarded as an intricate result of the relevant ideology, poetics, patronage and other socio-cultural factors.