Energy storage solutions are a vital component of the global transition toward renewable energy sources. The power-to-gas (PtG) concept, which stores surplus renewable energy in the form of methane, has therefore become increasingly relevant in recent years. At present, supported Ni nanoparticles are preferred as industrial catalysts for CO2 methanation due to their low cost and high methane selectivity. However, commercial Ni catalysts are not active enough in CO2 methanation to reach the high CO2 conversion (>99%) required by the specifications for injection in the natural gas grid. Herein we demonstrate the promise of promotion of Ni by Mn, another low-cost base metal, for obtaining very active CO2 methanation catalysts, with results comparable to more expensive precious metal-based catalysts. The origin of this improved performance is revealed by a combined approach of nanoscale characterization, mechanistic study, and density functional theory calculations. Nanoscale characterization with scanning transmission electron microscopy–energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (STEM-EDX) and X-ray absorption spectroscopy shows that NiMn catalysts consist of metallic Ni particles decorated by oxidic Mn2+ species. A mechanistic study combining IR spectroscopy of surface adsorbates, transient kinetic analysis with isotopically labeled CO2, density functional theory calculations, and microkinetics simulations ascertains that the MnO clusters enhance CO2 adsorption and facilitate CO2 activation. A macroscale perspective was achieved by simulating the Ni and NiMn catalytic activity in a Sabatier reactor, which revealed that NiMn catalysts have the potential to meet the demanding PtG catalyst performance requirements and can largely replace the need for expensive and scarce noble metal catalysts.
We prepared uniformly-sized Ni nanoparticles on ceria–zirconia (CZ) as model catalysts for CO2 methanation in the context of renewable energy storage. CZ was synthesized via a sol–gel method with Ni being introduced either via incipient-wetness impregnation on calcined CZ or as a colloidal Ni nanoparticle (NiNP) dispersion during sol–gel synthesis. Catalysts were characterized with XRD, N2 physisorption, H2-TPR, H2 chemisorption, XPS and HAADF-STEM with EDX mapping. The Ni/CZ (IWI) catalyst contained large Ni particles after reduction, whereas co-gelation led to NiNP encapsulated in CZ, the particles retaining their initial size of 4.5 nm obtained by the earlier colloidal synthesis. Encapsulated Ni@CZ exhibited superior catalytic activity and stability for CO2 methanation over Ni/CZ. A comparison of Ni@CZ with (encapsulated) Ni@SiO2 prepared from the same colloidal NiNP dispersion showed that CZ shows a strong synergy with Ni in CO2 methanation and results in an order of magnitude higher activity compared to SiO2.