Assessing the condition of sewer pipelines is a backbone process to plan for rehabilitation and maintenance work. The closed circuit-television (CCTV) method is the widely adopted method to record the inner condition of the pipelines, which is then interpreted by a practitioner. This paper presents a condition assessment framework for sewer pipelines using multiattribute utility theory (MAUT). The condition assessment model utilizes MAUT to generate several utility functions for four sewer pipeline defects: deformation, settled deposits, infiltration, and surface damage. A proposed surface damage evaluation methodology is presented to assess the surface damage defect for three different materials: reinforced concrete, vitrified clay, and ductile iron. An aggregated condition index is computed based on the relative importance weights of the studied defects and tested with several rounding types. The rounding up type produced the optimum results, and the values were compared with the Concordia Sewer Protocol (CSP) suggested methodology yielding an average difference between the two approaches of 3.33%; and a mean absolute error (MAE) of 0.33. A sensitivity analysis was then carried out to check the impact of the change of the relative importance weights on the overall index. The proposed methodology aims to provide information for asset managers about the severity of some sewer defects existing in sewer pipelines. In addition, it reinforces their plans for rehabilitation and maintenance by suggesting the existing condition of the sewer pipelines.
1 October 2016 in Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Authorities in Quebec, Canada, have been making considerable efforts to improve sewer networks across the province by using up-to-date technologies. To rehabilitate its sewer mains, Quebec has used several rehabilitation methods including slip lining, cement and epoxy lining, and cured-in-place pipe (CIPP).These replacement and rehabilitation techniques have been developed over the last four decades, with many arbitrary declarations made about the efficiency and performance of different rehabilitation techniques. This paper presents condition prediction models for CIPP rehabilitation of sewer mains. Regression analysis technique is used to develop these models, based on gathered and analyzed closed-circuit television (CCTV) inspection reports for Quebec CIPP rehabilitations. The models can predict the structural and operational conditions of CIPP rehabilitation on the basis of basic input such as pipe material, and rehabilitation type and date. They can also generate curves illustrating condition ...
1 February 2021 in Journal of Pipeline Systems Engineering and Practice
Sewer pipelines are a major component of any infrastructure. In fact, they are subject to deterioration through their service lives. Although researchers are pointing out the consequences of erosion voids in sewer pipelines, the literature lacks the evaluation and prediction of such a defect. This research’s main goal is to propose a model that can predict the condition of the erosion voids present outside sewer pipelines considering the fuzzy expert system. The methodology relies on different factors that are expected to contribute to the voids’ development and severity. Fuzzy membership functions are constructed for five identified factors. The aggregated index representing the condition of the studied defect is achieved by considering the relative weights of the factors collected from 32 experts. The model is implemented on two case studies. The first case study supplied average values of accuracy, precision, and true positive rate (TPR) of 83%, 80%, and 76%, respectively. The second case is used to associate the soil intrusion defect with the erosion voids condition. Accordingly, it concludes that higher soil intrusion percentages are observed in poor and critical erosion voids conditions. In addition, a regression analysis model is developed to study the relation between the structural grade of sewer pipelines and erosion voids conditions. The regression model produced a coefficient of determination ( ) of 70.0%, minimal errors, and a high average validity percentage (AVP). This research shall help decision-makers in studying erosion voids defect to avoid major rehabilitation costs and sinkholes.
1 October 2022 in Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Water distribution networks (WDNs) are complex interconnected networks that require extensive planning and maintenance to ensure good quality water is delivered to all consumers. The main task of WDNs is to provide consumers with a minimum acceptable level of supply (in terms of pressure, availability, and water quality) at all times under a range of operating conditions. However, the water infrastructure in North America signifies an urgent need of upgrading the aging and deteriorating distribution systems if they are to continue to provide consumers with reliable and safe water supplies. In this context, this research is proposing a new reliability model for assessing the mechanical/structural as well as hydraulic conditions of a WDN to identify failure-prone components and prioritize their renewal. The developed model provides a systematic and practical methodology to calculate the mechanical/structural reliability of the pipe and its accessories (valves, hydrants, and so on) through the consideration of historical failures of components. The research deployed pressure-dependent demand analysis to determine the hydraulic reliability of the network in meeting the pressure requirements and overall hydraulics of the network. The minimum-cut-set theory was implemented in both reliability assessments, and the outputs of the two models were integrated to provide a representative reliability of the network. A sensitivity analysis was followed to study the change in segments’ attributes on the mechanical/structural and hydraulic reliabilities. The approach was implemented on the City of London, Canada, network (north and south) to test its applicability. The developed model is expected to assist decision makers in integrating the failure records with the hydraulic simulation to plan for optimum intervention actions.
1 August 2020 in Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering
Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are facing significant deterioration due to aging and improper maintenance. Statistics Canada reported that 22% and 14% of the wastewater treatment plants in Alberta and Ontario, respectively, are in poor and very poor conditions. Because of the non-capital and capital improvement requirements for any WWTP, intervention decision-making tools are paramount. The objectives of this research were to develop an integrated condition rating model for the WWTP and an optimized maintenance, rehabilitation, and replacement (MR&R) intervention model. The condition assessment model was applied on case studies and the indices supplied by the operators were used to compare the results of model through the mean absolute error (MAE) calculation, which was minimal. To optimize the intervention decisions for various units of the WWTP, the binary integer programming was used. These models are expected to enhance the evaluation of WWTPs and facilitate intervention plans based on an optimized methodology.