The paper presents a physics-based method to calculate in real time the distribution of temperature in the active part of liquid immersed power transformers (LIPT) in a transient thermal processes during grid operation. The method is based on the detailed dynamic thermal-hydraulic network model (THNM). Commonly, up to now, lumped models have been used, whereby the temperatures are calculated at a few points (top-oil and hot-spot), and the parameters are determined from basic or extended temperature-rise tests and/or field operation. Numerous simplifications are made in such models and the accuracy of calculation decreases when the transformer operates outside the range of tested values (cooling stage, loading). The dynamic THNM reaches the optimum of accuracy and simplicity, being feasible for on-line application. The paper presents fundamental equations of dynamic THNM, which are structurally different from static THNM equations. The paper offers the numerical solver for the case of a closed-loop thermosyphon. To apply the method for real transformer grid operation, there is a need to develop details as in static THNM, which has been used to calculate the distribution of the temperatures in LIPT thermal design. The paper proves the concept of dynamic THNM using the experimental results of a closed-loop thermosyphon small-scale model, previously published by authors from McGill University in 2017. The comparison of dynamic THNM with measurements on that model are presented in the paper.
27 May 2022 in International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems
This paper presents the application of a detailed dynamic thermal-hydraulic network model (DTHNM) to real liquid-immersed power transformers (LIPTs). Unlike existing simple models based on ordinary differential equations (ODEs), such as ones from standards, the DTHNM is deeply rooted in physics and resolves many key issues, such as distributed heat accumulation, the dependency of losses on tap position, load, and conductor temperature, as well as the influence of ambient temperature and varying operating stages of cooling equipment. DTHNM delivers a time-varying global distribution of liquid flow inside the transformer tank and the distribution of flows and temperatures across each transformer part. It has been validated using field data from a three-phase 66 MVA transformer (summer and winter operating periods) and a single-phase 370 MVA transformer (60-hour extended temperature rise test). DTHNM closely matches the measured temperatures, whereas standard models show larger errors, especially under high-load and/or low-ambient conditions. The main contributions of this paper are: 1) extension of the detailed steady-state thermal-hydraulic network model (steady-state THNM) to a detailed dynamic model (DTHNM) for digital twin applications; 2) application of the model to large LIPTs with validation against measurements; 3) comparison of DTHNM accuracy with IEC and IEEE loading guide models; 4) analysis of practical issues including data requirements, computation time, real-time feasibility and limitations.
23 September 2024 in IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery
The paper presents the detailed dynamic thermal-hydraulic network model (THNM) for liquid-immersed power transformers (LIPT). Detailed static THNMs are prevalent in thermal design practice, but detailed dynamic THNM have not yet reached an adequate technology readiness level (TRL). Dynamic THNM describes local heat transfer and hydraulic phenomena in detail, integrating them into a global model of the complete transformer, which can be used for real-time applications. Consequently, a dynamic THNM provides a good foundation for creating a digital twin module of the transformer's transient thermal behavior during real grid operation. The paper explains the advanced detailed dynamic THNM and points out the differences from other existing approaches. It also describes the details of the model application to an experimental setup closely resembling a real transformer. The calculation results are compared with the experimental results and an error below 1.85 K in steady-state and 3.23 K after the first hour period from the cold start is observed for the discs' temperature. This study also shows that the execution time is shorter than the real thermal transient process, which is a criterion required for real-time applications.
One of the type tests on power transformers is heat run test, which checks that the characteristic winding and oil temperatures are below allowed values. This is necessary to prevent accelerated ageing and shortening of the transformer life if the temperatures are higher than the allowed values. In addition to the user's clear interest, manufacturers are also interested in the results of heat run tests, as they can verify and improve the accuracy of calculation methods and software [1]. Then they can increase the accuracy and reduce the safety margins of calculation methods, so they can change transformer construction and achieve temperatures that are much closer to the allowed ones. As the result of that, they can reduce material and production costs. The minimal test is defined by the IEC standard [2]. Due to the great mass and consequent great thermal capacity of the transformer parts, heat run tests take a very long time. The paper presents an algorithm, and its software implementation, which reduce the occupancy of test station, energy consumption and the total cost of performing heat run tests.