Landsat 8 Level 2 Collection 2 (L2C2) surface reflectance (SR) products are widely used in various scientific applications by the remote sensing community, where their accuracy is vital for reliable analysis. However, discrepancies have been observed at shorter wavelength bands, which can affect certain applications. This study investigates the root cause of these differences by analyzing the assumptions made in the Land Surface Reflectance Code (LaSRC), the atmospheric correction algorithm of Landsat 8, as currently implemented at United States Geological Survey Earth Resources Observation and Science (USGS EROS), and proposes a correction method. To quantify these discrepancies, ground truth SR measurements from the Radiometric Calibration Network (RadCalNet) and Arable Mark 2 sensors were compared with the Landsat 8 SR. Additionally, the surface pressure measurements from RadCalNet and the National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI) were evaluated against the LaSRC-calculated surface pressure values. The findings reveal that the discrepancies arose from using a single scene center surface pressure for the entire Landsat 8 scene pixels. The pressure-related discrepancies were most pronounced in the coastal aerosol and blue bands, with greater deviations observed in regions where the elevation of the study area differed substantially from the scene center, such as Railroad Valley Playa (RVUS) and Baotao Sand (BSCN). To address this issue, an exponential correction model was developed, reducing the mean error in the coastal aerosol band for RVUS from 0.0226 to 0.0029 (about two units of reflectance), which can be substantial for dark vegetative and water targets. In the blue band, there is a smaller improvement in the mean error, from 0.0095 to −0.0032 (about half a unit of reflectance). For the green band, the reduction in error was much less due to the significantly lesser impact of aerosol on this band. Overall, this study underscores the need for a more precise estimation of surface pressure in LaSRC to enhance the reliability of Landsat 8 SR products in remote sensing applications.
This paper evaluates the Arable Mark 2 sensor, an automated and low-cost radiometer, for its potential to retrieve surface reflectance data and validate orbital sensors such as the Landsat-8 (L8) Operational Land Imager (OLI) Level 2 product. While orbital sensors are widely used for monitoring solar radiation changes, managing natural resources, and understanding climatic trends, atmospheric effects can make it challenging to obtain accurate measurements. Equipped with multiple sensors, including long-wave and short-wave radiometers, the Arable Mark 2 sensor can measure upwelling and downwelling irradiance to calculate surface reflectance. To assess the accuracy and consistency of the Arable Mark 2 sensor, the study performed a cross-calibration using a ground truth measurement collected with the Analytical Spectral Device (ASD) as the reference point. Additionally, a spectral band adjustment factor (SBAF) was applied across the calibrated Arable surface reflectance to compare it against the orbital sensor. An automated library aided in calculating SBAF for the days with unavailable hyperspectral data. The study found that the Arable Mark 2 sensor can provide accurate surface reflectance data that can be used for orbital sensor validation. The Arable sensor was successfully calibrated against the ASD FieldSpec with an average difference of less than 1/10 reflectance unit (reflectance unit = 0.01) for the blue, green, yellow, and red bands. The red-edge and NIR-1 bands showed an average difference of less than 1/2 reflectance units, while the NIR-2 band had an average difference of less than 1/10 reflectance unit of calibration accuracy. The calibrated Arable surface reflectance data was then compared against orbital sensor surface reflectance data, and the results showed good agreement between the two datasets. The study concludes that the low-cost and automated nature of the Arable Mark 2 sensor makes it a promising tool for surface reflectance retrieval and orbital sensor validation.
This study addresses the critical need for radiometrically accurate and consistent hyperspectral data as the remote sensing community moves towards a hyperspectral world. Previous calibration efforts on Hyperion, the first on-orbit hyperspectral sensors, have exhibited temporal stability and absolute accuracy limitations. This work has developed and validated a novel cross-calibration methodology to address these challenges. Also, this work adds two other hyperspectral sensors, DLR Earth Sensing Imaging Spectrometer (DESIS) and Earth Surface mineral Dust Source Investigation instrument (EMIT), to maintain temporal continuity and enhance spatial coverage along with spectral resolution. The study established a robust approach for calibrating Hyperion using DESIS and EMIT. The methodology involves several key processes. First is a temporal stability assessment on Extended Pseudo Invariant Calibration Sites (EPICS) Cluster13–Global Temporal Stable (GTS) over North Africa (Cluster13–GTS) using Landsat Sensors Landsat 7 (ETM+), Landsat 8 (OLI). Second, a temporal trend correction model was developed for DESIS and Hyperion using statistically selected models. Third, absolute calibration was developed for DESIS and EMIT using multiple vicarious calibration sites, resulting in an overall absolute calibration uncertainty of 2.7–5.4% across the DESIS spectrum and 3.1–6% on non-absorption bands for EMIT. Finally, Hyperion was cross-calibrated using calibrated DESIS and EMIT as reference (with traceability to ground reference) with a calibration uncertainty within the range of 7.9–12.9% across non-absorption bands. The study also validates these calibration coefficients using OLI over Cluster13–GTS. The validation provided results suggesting a statistical similarity between the absolute calibrated hyperspectral sensors mean TOA (top-of-atmosphere) reflectance with that of OLI. This study offers a valuable contribution to the community by fulfilling the above-mentioned needs, enabling more reliable intercomparison, and combining multiple hyperspectral datasets for various applications.