As the UK makes steps to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions to net zero, electric heat pumps are proposed as a solution for heat decarbonisation in the majority of homes. This paper used smart meter data to examine the gas and electricity consumption of 187 homes with air source heat pumps installed under the Green Homes Grant incentive scheme. It was found that 1 year after the installation, 24% of households were still connected to the gas distribution network and that 21% of households still used gas, either for cooking or for heating. We reflect on the implications of this ongoing gas connection and use in the light of the UK’s net zero plans, and discuss how households could be supported by government to fully transition away from using natural gas. Practical application: This paper found that around a quarter of households in a sample of UK homes were still connected to the gas network 1 year after installing a heat pump, with most of these still using gas for cooking or heating. It raises important questions about why a minority of households continue to use gas and whether heat pumps may not meet their needs; makes proposals for practical amendments to encourage electric cooking or incorporate gas disconnection as part of current retrofit policies; and situates the findings within the wider context of meeting the UK’s net-zero targets.
The lockdowns introduced to prevent the spread of COVID-19 had huge impacts, as people were largely confined to their homes. It could be expected that residential energy use would increase while non-residential decreased, however the picture is not so clear. Here three complementary datasets on different scales are used to explore changes in building energy use during two UK lockdowns: the complete building stock of Great Britain, a sample of approximately 1000 residential buildings, and one of about 24,000 residential boilers. Energy-signature analysis was used for the building data to estimate the changes in demand for space heating and other uses, with the boiler data able to separate space and water heating and explore changes in these. In the 2020 lockdown residential energy consumption for water heating and appliances increased, with decreased use for space heating, resulting in a reduction in total energy use during the heating season. In the 2021 lockdown total energy consumption changed little, however a decrease in the use of gas space heating was observed. The residential changes counteracted non-domestic changes, resulting in little difference in national energy consumption. These results highlight how longitudinal datasets enabled by Internet of Things-enabled devices can be crucial as an evidence base for research. Policy relevance The impacts on national energy consumption of increased time spent at home provide an important context for the pursuit of net zero targets, particularly with the rise in flexible working seen since 2020. That little change was seen overall could be due to the energy use in non-domestic buildings not decreasing proportionately to their decrease in use during national lockdowns, and thus seeking to lower non-domestic energy use to account for lower utilisation of spaces could deliver carbon and cost savings. This could be achieved through measures such as automated switch-off services, demand controlled heating and ventilation, and reduction in space. The finding that drastic changes were not made to home heating behaviours could have implications for future demand-side response schemes, indicating that perhaps occupants are happy to adapt to cooler conditions by achieving comfort in other ways.
Understanding household energy demand patterns is essential for effective energy system planning and policy design. Building on previous cluster analysis of common daily demand profiles, this study identifies household electricity and gas ‘demand archetypes’ which capture the typical summer and winter weekday demand profiles for each home using modal daily demand profiles. We apply logistic regression with household survey data to identify potential explanatory factors. Our study uses half-hourly smart meter data from the Smart Energy Research Lab Observatory in Great Britain between November 2021 and August 2022; 9844 households with electricity data and 7251 with gas data after filtering. We find that household gas demand archetypes show much greater variability between seasons than electricity archetypes, consistent with seasonal variations in gas heating needs. Household demand archetypes with a morning and/or evening peak are the most prevalent in both seasons for electricity and gas. However, a substantial share of households exhibits highly variable demand profiles in both seasons, indicating inconsistent and possibly flexible routines. Logistic regression analysis reveals strong correlations between microgeneration and a midday trough in electricity demand, while electric vehicle ownership increases the likelihood of a variable demand profile. Financial wellbeing and family structure also show correlations with demand archetypes, with lower-income households more likely to exhibit variable and peak-time gas archetypes; perhaps indicating efforts to reduce costs. Our findings highlight the value of analysing household electricity and gas demand archetypes for different seasons and offer important insights for demand-side energy management, forecasting and policy.